1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. Kings County Supreme Courts
  5. Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

Case Last Refreshed: 7 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Sonia Tulier, filed a(n) Premises Liability - Torts case represented by Jaffe, Michael Eliot, against Lie Dong Wen, Mei Quin Zhang, The City Of New York, Yun Yan Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, (total of 5) See All represented by Counsel, Corporation, Struller, Jesse, Tadros, Veronika, Yong, Jeffrey P, in the jurisdiction of Kings County. This case was filed in Kings County Superior Courts with Lawrence Knipel presiding.

Case Details for Sonia Tulier v. Lie Dong Wen , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

Lawrence Knipel

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

April 17, 2015

Category

Torts - Other Negligence (Premises)

Last Refreshed

October 12, 2023

Practice Area

Torts

Filing Location

Kings County, NY

Matter Type

Premises Liability

Parties for Sonia Tulier v. Lie Dong Wen , et al.

Plaintiffs

Sonia Tulier

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Jaffe, Michael Eliot

Defendants

Lie Dong Wen

Mei Quin Zhang

The City Of New York

Yun Yan Zhang

Zi Xiong Zhang

Attorneys for Defendants

Counsel, Corporation

Struller, Jesse

Tadros, Veronika

Yong, Jeffrey P

Case Documents for Sonia Tulier v. Lie Dong Wen , et al.

for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION  (Motion #4)

Date: November 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #4)

Date: November 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #4)

Date: November 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #4)

Date: November 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #4)

Date: November 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - H  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - I  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #5)

Date: December 13, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #6)

Date: December 15, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

ORDER - OTHER  (Motion #4)

Date: February 09, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #5)

Date: March 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION  (Motion #7)

Date: March 06, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #6)

Date: March 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY

Date: June 13, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: August 29, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #5)

Date: April 18, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #7)

Date: April 18, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS  (Motion #7)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS  (Motion #7)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION

Date: April 18, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #7)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE  (Motion #7)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION  (Motion #7)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY

Date: June 12, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #6)

Date: April 18, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #7)

Date: April 18, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #6)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION  (Motion #6)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION  (Motion #5)

Date: June 07, 2023
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #4) Plaintiff's Verfied Bill of Particulars and attachments Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - J  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - I  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - H  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH  (Motion #4)

Date: June 09, 2022
for Sonia Tulier V. Lie Dong Wen, The City Of New York, Mei Quin Zhang, Zi Xiong Zhang, Yun Yan Zhang

COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION

Date: April 17, 2015

Case Events for Sonia Tulier v. Lie Dong Wen , et al.

Date Type Description
August 29, 2023 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Hon. Judge Melendez - Sonia Tulier
View Document
June 13, 2023 AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
View Document
June 12, 2023 AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
View Document
June 07, 2023 STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS (Motion #7)
Counter-Statement of Material Facts - Tulier
View Document
June 07, 2023 RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS (Motion #7)
Response to Defenant's Statement of Material Facts - Tulier
View Document
June 07, 2023 AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE (Motion #5)
Affidavit of Service - Aff in Opp and MOL in Opp
View Document
June 07, 2023 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION (Motion #7)
Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for SJ - Tulier
View Document
June 07, 2023 AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION (Motion #5)
Affirmation in Opposition to SJ - Tulier
View Document
June 07, 2023 AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE (Motion #7)
Affidavit of Service - Response to Counter Stmt, Aff in Opp and Memo of Law in Support
View Document
June 07, 2023 AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION (Motion #7)
Affirmation in Opposition to SJ - Tulier
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.