1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. New York County Supreme Courts
  5. New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawy

Case Last Refreshed: 5 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Asian American Bar Association Of New York, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc., Bronx County Bar Association, Brooklyn Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, (total of 10) See All filed a(n) General Torts - Torts case represented by Dell, Michael J, Moff, Jason Michael, Schwartzberg, Nathan, against New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance, The City Of New York, The State Of New York, represented by Bhat, Anjali, Di Silvio, Lorenzo Giorgio, Pines, Jonathan Lewis, Sanders, Charles Fernardo, in the jurisdiction of New York County. This case was filed in New York County Superior Courts with Lisa S. Headley presiding.

Case Details for Asian American Bar Association Of New York v. New York City Department Of Finance , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

Lisa S. Headley

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

July 26, 2021

Category

Torts - Other (Constitutional Rights)

Last Refreshed

December 03, 2023

Practice Area

Torts

Filing Location

New York County, NY

Matter Type

General Torts

Case Complaint Summary

This is a complaint filed in the Supreme Court of New York, New York County by the New York County Lawyers' Association along with the Bronx County Bar Association and the Queens County Lawyers' Association. They are suing the State of New York, the ...

Subscribe to see entire Complaint Summary

Parties for Asian American Bar Association Of New York v. New York City Department Of Finance , et al.

Plaintiffs

Asian American Bar Association Of New York

Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc.

Bronx County Bar Association

Brooklyn Bar Association

Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County

Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association

Metropolitan Black Bar Association

New York County Lawyers Association

Queens County Bar Association

Richmond County Bar Association

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Dell, Michael J

Moff, Jason Michael

Schwartzberg, Nathan

Defendants

New York City Department Of Finance

Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

The City Of New York

The State Of New York

Attorneys for Defendants

Bhat, Anjali

Di Silvio, Lorenzo Giorgio

Pines, Jonathan Lewis

Sanders, Charles Fernardo

Other Parties

David Heraty (Non Party)

Heraty, David Anthony (Attorney)

Kings County Criminal Bar Association (Non Party)

Winslow, Darran David (Attorney)

Case Documents for Asian American Bar Association Of New York v. New York City Department Of Finance , et al.

for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

COMPLAINT

Date: July 26, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - K  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 72  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 70  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT

Date: April 21, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY  (Motion #001) Reply Affirmation Of Michael J. Dell in Further Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for a Preliminary Inju

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 77  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: April 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 73  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - N  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT  (Motion #001)

Date: March 28, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIRMATION

Date: April 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE  (Motion #001) Response to NYSCEF No. 130 (letter from City Defendants counsel) and NYSCEF No. 132 (letter from Cou

Date: June 13, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: March 03, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIDAVIT

Date: March 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - J  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 35  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 54  (Motion #001) Testimony of T. Andrew Brown, President, NYSBA, before the NYSSFC and the NYSAWMC on the Public Prot

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 44  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 56  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 51  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 53  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: June 06, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 62  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 49  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 34  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 31  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 61  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 43  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 42  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 30  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 41  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: August 25, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 63  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 71  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION

Date: April 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE

Date: August 16, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 57  (Motion #001) Testimony of Patricia Warth, Director of the NYSILS, before the NYSSFC and the NYSAWMC on the Public

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: April 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 52  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 38  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 37  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 39  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 50  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 6  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: March 03, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 74  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 8  (Motion #001) 3/2/ 2021 letter Chief Judge DiFiore, sent to Assembly leaders regarding Assigned Counsel Rates in N

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 9  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 75  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 18  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 59  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 17  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 12  (Motion #001) Testimony of Chief Administrative Judge Lawrence Marks, before the NYSSFC and the NYSAWMC on the Pub

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 40  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: July 26, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 27  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 15  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 47  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 10  (Motion #001) Written submission of Deputy Administrative Judge Anne-Marie Jolly to the Chief Judges 2021 Hearings

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION

Date: July 25, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 48  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 25  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 58  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 69  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 32  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 23  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: March 07, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: July 30, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIRMATION

Date: March 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 60  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: March 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 36  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 20  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 24  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: May 10, 2023
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 28  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 46  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

SUMMONS

Date: July 26, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - I  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 45  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 76  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 55  (Motion #001) Testimony of Susan C. Bryant, Executive Director, NYSDA, Inc., before the NYSSFC and the NYSAWMC on

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 66  (Motion #001) NYSILS Standards for Establishing and Administering Assigned Counsel Programs, Black Letter Standard

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 64  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 67  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY  (Motion #001) Reply Affirmation Of Brian Zimmerman in Further Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for a Preliminary Inju

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 11  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 16  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: June 27, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: June 08, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 33  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: June 08, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 29  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - H  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 21  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: March 07, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - P  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: June 13, 2023
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - L  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 14  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - O  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: July 05, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

REMITTITUR

Date: July 06, 2023
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

NOTICE OF APPEAL

Date: August 25, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 19  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 26  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 68  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

COMPLAINT (AMENDED)

Date: September 30, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT  (Motion #001) Memorandum of Law in Support of Plaintiffs' Application for an Order to Show Cause and Motion for a

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

ORDER - OTHER (MOTION RELATED)  (Motion #001)

Date: March 17, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE  (Motion #001)

Date: February 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #001)

Date: April 04, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 13  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 22  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 5  (Motion #001) 2/26/2019 letter Chief Judge DiFiore sent to Assembly leaders regarding Assigned Counsel Rates in Ne

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER

Date: October 07, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - M  (Motion #001)

Date: April 18, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 7  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP  (Motion #001) Affirmation of Michael J. Dell in Support of Plaintiffs' Application for an Order to Show Cause and

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

ANSWER

Date: November 17, 2021
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 65  (Motion #001) NYSBA Report of the Criminal Justice Section and the Committee on Mandated Representation: The Need

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 3  (Motion #001)

Date: February 02, 2022
for New York County Lawyers Association, Bronx County Bar Association, Queens County Bar Association, Richmond County Bar Association, Assigned Counsel Association Of New York State, Inc. (Aca-Nys, Inc.), Macon B. Allen Black Bar Association, Latino Lawyers Association Of Queens County, Brooklyn Bar Association, Metropolitan Black Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association Of New York V. The State Of New York, The City Of New York, New York City Department Of Finance, Sherif Soliman In His Official Capacity As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Finance

EXHIBIT(S)  - 4  (Motion #001) 1/22/2022 statement of Chief Judge Janet DiFiore to the Annual Meeting of the NYSBA House of Delegat

Date: February 02, 2022

Case Events for Asian American Bar Association Of New York v. New York City Department Of Finance , et al.

Date Type Description
July 06, 2023 REMITTITUR
View Document
June 13, 2023 Notice of Entry with Appellate Division Order
View Document
May 10, 2023 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
August 25, 2022 NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)
View Document
August 25, 2022 NOTICE OF APPEAL
View Document
July 26, 2022 NOTICE OF ENTRY
View Document
July 25, 2022 DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
View Document
July 05, 2022 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
June 27, 2022 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
June 13, 2022 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE (Motion #001) Response to NYSCEF No. 130 (letter from City Defendants counsel) and NYSCEF No. 132 (letter from Cou
Response to NYSCEF No. 130 (letter from City Defendants counsel) and NYSCEF No. 132 (letter from Cou ... show more
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.