1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. Richmond County Supreme Courts
  5. Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz To

Case Last Refreshed: 3 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Benedict Loparrino, Carolyn Grimando, Dennis Strk, Heather Clark, (total of 18) See All filed a(n) Agency Action - Administrative case represented by Sidhu Gibson, Sujata, Sussman, Michael H, against City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education, represented by Haider, Bilal Husain, Linnane, Kathleen Maura, Minicucci, Lora, in the jurisdiction of Richmond County. This case was filed in Richmond County Superior Courts with Ralph Porzio presiding.

Case Details for Amaryllis Ruiz Toro v. City Of New York , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

Ralph Porzio

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

February 11, 2023

Category

Special Proceedings - Other (Hybrid Article 78)

Last Refreshed

January 30, 2024

Practice Area

Administrative

Filing Location

Richmond County, NY

Matter Type

Agency Action

Parties for Amaryllis Ruiz Toro v. City Of New York , et al.

Plaintiffs

Amaryllis Ruiz Toro

Benedict Loparrino

Carolyn Grimando

Dennis Strk

Heather Clark

Ingrid Romero

Joan Giammarino

Margaret Chu

Michael Kane

Natasha Solon

Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu

Robert Gladding

Sasha Delgado

Stephanie Dicapua

Teachers For Choice

Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members,

Trinidad Smith

William Castro

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Sidhu Gibson, Sujata

Sussman, Michael H

Defendants

City Of New York

New York City Department Of Education

Attorneys for Defendants

Haider, Bilal Husain

Linnane, Kathleen Maura

Minicucci, Lora

Case Documents for Amaryllis Ruiz Toro v. City Of New York , et al.

for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 5  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 4  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 3  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION  (Motion #004)

Date: October 16, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT

Date: October 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION

Date: October 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION OF ATTORNEY FEES  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

JUDGMENT - (PROPOSED) SUBMIT JUDGMENT PER JUDGES DECISION

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL

Date: October 06, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #004)

Date: October 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: January 18, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT  (Motion #005) Also applies to Motion #4 - note correction for typo, which should apply to both (2024 not 2023 retu

Date: December 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT  (Motion #005)

Date: November 15, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #001)

Date: January 16, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )

Date: October 04, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #001)

Date: January 16, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #004)

Date: November 20, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT  (Motion #004)

Date: December 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT A - Motion for Attorney Fees and Declaration of Sujata Gibson Submitted in Support of Motion

Date: January 16, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY

Date: January 17, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF ENTRY  (Motion #003)

Date: November 15, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 12  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 11  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: January 03, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 7  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 9  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY  (Motion #005)

Date: January 17, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #005)

Date: November 15, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE

Date: January 08, 2024
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: November 15, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 6  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 8  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 10  (Motion #001)

Date: November 08, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

PETITION

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 4

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 11

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 13

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 9

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 3

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 12

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 10

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 15

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 5

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 14

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 6

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 35

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 16

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 19

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 26

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 18

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 22

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 7

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 24

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 31

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 17

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 20

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 29

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 34

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 23

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

RJI -RE: OTHER

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 32

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 28

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 30

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 33

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 21

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 27

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 8

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 36

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 25

Date: February 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

PETITION (AMENDED)

Date: February 14, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )

Date: March 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - SO ORDERED

Date: March 13, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 6  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 3  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 5  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 4  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 7  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY

Date: May 17, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION  (Motion #003)

Date: May 19, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: June 26, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #002)

Date: July 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #003)

Date: June 26, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE

Date: June 16, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY

Date: July 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

ORDER - INTERIM

Date: July 19, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY

Date: July 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: May 23, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION  (Motion #002)

Date: July 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION

Date: July 19, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT

Date: June 05, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE  (Motion #001)

Date: July 31, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - S  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - T  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT T - Solon RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - H  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - I  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT I - Kane RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - J  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - L  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT L - Clark RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - O  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - M  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - K  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT K - Chu RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - Q  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT Q - Nwaifejokwu RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: August 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - N  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT N - Giammarino Letters to DOE and Dec 6 2021 Certified Receipts Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - P  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT P - LoParrino statement Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: August 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION

Date: August 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #001)

Date: August 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - R  (Motion #001) EXHIBIT R - Romero RA Request Documents Redacted per 22 NYCRR

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - U  (Motion #001)

Date: August 10, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING

Date: September 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF ENTRY *Corrected*

Date: September 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION

Date: September 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 5  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE

Date: September 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: September 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: September 11, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY

Date: August 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2  (Motion #001)

Date: August 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: May 03, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION

Date: May 12, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 14  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 3  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 6  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 9  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 16  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 15  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 7  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 17  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 10  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 8  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 21  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 19  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 12  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW  (Motion #002)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 18  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 11  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF MOTION

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 20  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #002)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

AFFIRMATION  (Motion #002)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 4  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 13  (Motion #001)

Date: April 07, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION

Date: May 03, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT

Date: May 03, 2023
for Stephanie Dicapua, Michael Kane, William Castro, Margaret Chu, Heather Clark, Sasha Delgado, Joan Giammarino, Robert Gladding, Carolyn Grimando, Benedict Loparrino, Nwakaego Nwaifejokwu, Ingrid Romero, Trinidad Smith, Natasha Solon, Amaryllis Ruiz Toro, Dennis Strk, Teachers For Choice Individually And On Behalf Of Its Members, V. City Of New York, New York City Department Of Education

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1  (Motion #003)

Date: May 12, 2023

Case Events for Amaryllis Ruiz Toro v. City Of New York , et al.

Date Type Description
January 18, 2024 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
January 17, 2024 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
View Document
January 17, 2024 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY (Motion #005)
Reply Memorandum of Law in Further Support of Motion to Reargue Cross-Motion
View Document
January 16, 2024 EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #001)
EXHIBIT B - Kane v de Blasio Complaint and Amended Complaint
View Document
January 16, 2024 AFFIRMATION (Motion #001)
Respondents' Opposition to Petitioners' Fees Request
View Document
January 16, 2024 EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #001) EXHIBIT A - Motion for Attorney Fees and Declaration of Sujata Gibson Submitted in Support of Motion
EXHIBIT A - Motion for Attorney Fees and Declaration of Sujata Gibson Submitted in Support of Motion ... show more
View Document
January 08, 2024 STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE
Stipulation re. Proposed Judgment Briefing Schedule
View Document
January 03, 2024 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
View Document
December 07, 2023 STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT (Motion #005) Also applies to Motion #4 - note correction for typo, which should apply to both (2024 not 2023 retu
Also applies to Motion #4 - note correction for typo, which should apply to both (2024 not 2023 retu ... show more
View Document
December 07, 2023 STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT (Motion #004)
Also applies to Motion 005
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.