Melissa Pixley Individually And In His/Her Capacity On Behalf Of All Other Persons Similarly Situated Et Al Vs. Geoffrey E Snyder In His/Her Capacity Commissioner Of The Massachusetts Department Of Revenue Et Al

Amended: amended complaint filed by Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Rescript received from Appeals Court; judgment REVERSED in part-The portion of the judgment dismissing the plaintiffs' claim for declaratory judgment is reversed, and the portion of the judgment dismissing the plaintiffs' claim for injunctive relief is vacated. The Judgment is otherwise affirmed. The case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion of the Appeals Court. Green, C.J., Henry, & Englander, JJ. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Green, Esq., Julie Elisabeth (Attorney) on behalf of Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Attorney appearance On this date Richard S Weitzel, Esq. added as Attorney for the Commonwealth for Defendant Geoffrey E. Snyder as the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue, FILED.

Rule 9A list of documents filed. Judge: Agostini, Hon. John A

Attorney appearance electronically filed. On this date Chelsea Kim Choi, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated On this date Chelsea Kim Choi, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated On this date Chelsea Kim Choi, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated

Notice of assembly of record sent to Counsel Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Worth, Esq., William A (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Hanson, Esq., Kirk Gerhard (Attorney) on behalf of Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Green, Esq., Julie Elisabeth (Attorney) on behalf of Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Appeal: Statement of the Case on Appeal (Cover Sheet). Applies To: Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Notice to Clerk of the Appeals Court of Assembly of Record Applies To: Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Service Returned for Defendant Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue: Service made in hand; on 07/14/2017 at 12:15 p.m. to Nestor Morales, at Mass Dept of Revenue, One Ashburton Place, Boston MA 02108, filed. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Harrington, Esq., Andrea C (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Appeal Interlocutory Appeal filed on 07/07/2021 by Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated : William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated : William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated Memorandum and Order, entered on the docket on February 15, 20218, granting the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Motion to Dismiss and Dismissing Counts 1 through 6 of Plaintiffs' Complaint and Order entered on the docket on February 15, 20218 dismissing the defendant, Michael J. Hefferman, FILED.

Attorney appearance On this date Thomas M Elcock, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Worth, Esq., William A (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Notice of appeal of Memorandum and Order entered on 02/15/2019 (Agostini, J), filed. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Attorney appearance On this date William A Worth, Esq. dismissed/withdrawn as Private Counsel for Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant) Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Worth, Esq., William A (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Stipulation of dismissal without Prejudice as to Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's original complaint Judge: Agostini, Hon. John A

Notice of docket entry received from Appeals Court On March 20, 2018, the following order was entered on the docket of the above-referenced case: RE#1: Absent the entry of a separate and final judgment as to DOR per Mass. R. Civ. P. 54(b), the matter is not ripe for appellate judicial review. Accordingly, the petition is denied (Agnes, J). Certified copy mailed to counsel.

MEMORANDUM & ORDER: on Commissioner of Revenue's motion to dismiss entered-Counts 1 through 6 stand dismissed (Agostini, J.). Copies certified to counsel Judge: Agostini, Hon. John A Applies To: Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Reply Memorandum In Further Support Of His Motion To Dismiss.

Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Memorandum in opposition to the Commissioner Of Revenue's Motion To Dismiss

Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Memorandum in support of Motion To Dismiss

Rule 9A notice of filing

Service Returned for Defendant Best Buy Stores L.P.: Service made in hand; on 07/14/2017 at 9:45 a.m. to wit, by delivering to Ross DePina, to Best Buys Stores LP, at CT Corporation Systems, 155 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston MA 02110, filed. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Harrington, Esq., Andrea C (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Defendant(s) Michael J Hefferman Individually and in his/her capacity As the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Motion to Dismiss

Service Returned for Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC: Service made in hand; on 07/14/2017 at 9:50 a.m. to wit, to Ross DePina, at CT Corporation System, 155 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston MA 02110, filed. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Harrington, Esq., Andrea C (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Original civil complaint filed.

Service Returned for Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless: Service made in hand; on 07/14/2017 at 9:45 a.m. to wit, by delivering to Ross DePina, at Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, Verizon Wireless Telecom, Inc. at CT Corporation System, 155 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston MA 02110, filed.

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT M - true and correct copy of AT&T's wireless customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT O - true and correct copy of Mr. Cavanaugh's June 18, 2023 customer service summary, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT A - contract accepted dated 11/9/2012, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Notice of Corporate Disclosure Statement, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Notice of Filing, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT C - wireless customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Reply/Sur-reply Response by the Commissioner of Revenue to the Motions to Compel Arbitration with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Reply/Sur-reply Reply Memorandum in support of Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to Compel Arbitration and to Stay Litigation, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Affidavit-Supplemental Declaration of Jennifer K. Sharp in support of Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to Compel Arbitration and to Stay Litigation, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT L - true and correct copy of Mr. Cavanaugh's February 2, 2019 customer service summary, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT N - true and correct copy of AT&T's records reflecting the electronic consents obtained from Mr. Cavanaugh, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT I - true and correct copy of Mr. Kahan's August 2, 2023 customer service survey, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT P - true and correct copy of the text of the email notice sent to existing wireless customers, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT J - a true and correct copy of AT&T's current consumer service agreement, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT E - record signature of captured during transaction, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT K- true and correct copy of AT&T's record of the signature captured during transaction, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT G - correct screenshot from AT7&T records showing receipt, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBITS H - copy of AT&T record of the signature, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT B - William Hillman contract, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT F - Mr. Hillman's June 9, 2022 customer service summary, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Affidavit - Declaration of Jennifer K. Sharp in support of defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to Compel arbitration and to stay litigation, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT D-copy of customer service agreement of Mr. Hillman's 2/27/2922 transaction, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Opposition to Plaintiffs' OPPOSITION to Defendants' Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Proceedings, FILED. filed by Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situatedwith Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

AT&T Mobility LLC's Memorandum in support of Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to Compel arbitration and to stay litigation, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Response to Motions to Compel Arbitration with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT A (Terms), FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT B - email, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant) record signature

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT C - (order recap for William Hillman), FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Reply/Sur-reply Best Buy's REPLY in support of its Motion to Compel Arbitration with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Affidavit-Declaration of Lauren Wallen, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to compel arbitration and to stay litigation with Rule C Certificate and Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Best Buy Stores L.P., Best Buy Co., Inc.'s Notice of filing and list of documents. 1. Defendants Best Buy Stores, LP and Best Buy Inc.'s Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Proceedings pending arbitration; 2. Defendants Best Buy Stores, LP and Best Buy Inc.'s Memorandum of Law in support of their motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings pending arbitration; 3. Declaration of Susan Fletcher; 4. Declaration of Jeremy Greene; 5. Declaration of Angela Mattox; 6. Declaration of Lauren Wallen; 7. Response by the Commissioner of Revenue to the motions to compel arbitration; 8. Plaintiffs' Opposition to defendants' motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings; 9. Best Buy's reply in support of its motion to compel arbitration; and 10 Best Buy Stores, LP and Best Buy Inc.'s Corporate Disclosure Statement, with Certificate of Service. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Defendant Best Buy Co., Inc., Best Buy Stores L.P.'s Statement of Corporate Disclosure Statement with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Affidavit-Declaration of Jeremy Greene, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Affidavit-Declaration of Angela Mattox, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Affidavit-Declaration of Susan Fletcher, FILED.

Best Buy Stores L.P.'s Memorandum in support of Motion to Compel arbitration and stay proceedings pending arbitration with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Assented to Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Ann H. Rakestraw and Rachel E. Mueller for the Defendant. With Exhibits including Registrations/Receipts, Affidavit of Ann H Rakestraw and Affidavit of Rachel E. Mueller both in Support of the Motion for Pro Hac Vice. With Certificate of Service. FILED Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Defendant Best Buy Stores L.P., Best Buy Co., Inc.'s Motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings pending arbitration with Certificate of Service, Request for Hearing, and Certificate of 9C Conference, FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant)

Attorney appearance electronically filed.

Plaintiffs Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Assented to Motion to Amend the Schedule for Filing Responsive Pleadings, Motions to Compel Arbitration and Motions for Preliminary Injunction. With Certificate of Service. FILED Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant)

Attorney appearance On this date Matthew W Thomson, Esq. added for Plaintiff Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated

Opposition to Plaintiffs' OPPOSITION to Defendants' Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Proceedings with Certificate of Service, FILED. filed by Applies To: Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Attorney appearance On this date Shannon Liss-Riordan, Esq. added for Plaintiff Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated

Plaintiffs, Defendants Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue, AT&T Mobility LLC, Best Buy Stores L.P., Best Buy Co., Inc., Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless, Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Assented to Motion to Extend the Time by Which the Defendants have to File a Responsive Pleading to the Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint (from 9/15/2023 to 10/13/2023). With Certificate of Service. FILED Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Weitzel, Esq., Richard S (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to allow the appearance of Daniel E. Jones Pro Hac Vice (unopposed), with Certificate of Service, and Exhibit A Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Attorney appearance On this date Richard S Weitzel, Esq. dismissed/withdrawn as Attorney for the Commonwealth for Defendant Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue

Attorney appearance On this date Roger H Randall, Esq. added for Defendant Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue, FILED Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Motion to allow the appearance of Archis A. Parasharami Pro Hac Vice (unopposed), with Certificate of Service, and Exhibit A FILED Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Motion to admit Michael Ross pro hac vice as counsel for defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless (Unopposed) with Certificate of Service and Exhibit A (Affidavit of Michael Ross) and B (Registration Statement from Board of Bar Overseers), FILED.

Plaintiff, Defendant Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue, Best Buy Stores L.P., Best Buy Co., Inc., Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless, AT&T Mobility LLC, Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Joint Motion to amend the schedule for filing responsive pleadings, motion to compel arbitration and motion for a preliminary injunction, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC, Best Buy Co., Inc., Best Buy Stores L.P., Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Weitzel, Esq., Richard S (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc., Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Green, Esq., Julie Elisabeth (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Motion to Allow the Appearance of Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (UNOPPOSED Motion) With Certificate of Service and Exhibit A: Board of Overseers Registration Statement for Pro hac Vice Attorneys Regarding Julie R. Offerman. FILED Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

General correspondence regarding Notice of Attorney appearance for Attorney Matthew P. Horvitz as Counsel for Defendant, Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC with Certificate of Service, FILED Applies To: Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Motion to Allow the Appearance of C. Larry Carbo, III Pro Hac Vice (UNOPPOSED Motion) With Certificate of Service and Exhibit A: Board of Overseaeers Registration Statement for Pro Hac Vice Attorneys regarding C. Larry Carbo, III. FILED Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Attorney appearance electronically filed. Notice of Appearance of Attorney Michael T. Maroney for Defendant's Best Buy Stores LP. and Best Buy Co Inc. With Certificate of Service. FILED Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc., Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant)

Service Returned for Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC: Service accepted by counsel; FILED.

Affidavit -- Verification on the Class Action Complaint and Jury Demand by Plaintiff Melissa Pixley, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Service Returned for Defendant Best Buy Co., Inc.: Service accepted by counsel-FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT; FILED. Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant)

MEMORANDUM & ORDER: on Defendants' Motions to Compel Arbitration and Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction entered-...¿(1) The Vendors' motions to compel arbitration is ALLOWED; (2) The plaintiff's request for dismissal of the claims is DENIED, however, the litigation is STAYED pending resolution of the arbitrations; (3) The plaintiffs' motion for preliminary injunctions is DENIED; (4) The defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC's request for attorneys' fees is DENIED (Agostini, J.) Judge: Agostini, Hon. John A Applies To: Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Grill Pro Hac Vice, Michael A (Other interested party); Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Green, Esq., Julie Elisabeth (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Defendant AT&T Mobility LLC's Request for hearing on March 21, 2024 with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 8, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Notice of Filing and list of documents. 1. Cellular Sales' motion to compel individual arbitrations of and stay plaintiffs' claims; 2. Cellular Sales' memorandum in support of motion to compel individual arbitrations of and stay plaintiffs' claims; 3. Cellular Sales' reply in support of motion to compel individual arbitrations of and stay plaintiffs' claims; 4. Response by the Commission of Revenue to the motions to compel arbitration; 5. Affidavit of compliance with Superior Court Rule 9A and Rule 9C; and 6. Corporate Disclosure Statement. Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 6, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 5, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 7, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 4, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 3, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Statement of Corporate Disclosure, FILED. Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 2, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Exhibit 1, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Exhibits/Appendix Table of Exhibits. 1. Mass. DOR Directive 11-2 2. Mass DOR Letter Ruling 85-27, Lease and Installment Sale, Distinguished (February 11, 1985) 3. Mass. DOR Letter Ruling 83-17, Lease and Installment Sale, Distinguished (Mar. 23, 1983) 4. Chart of Allegations 5. Declaration of Nicholas v. Mento (Verizon) 6. Declaration of David B. Spradlin (AT&T) 7. Declaration of Stephen Harris (Best Buy) 8. Declaration of Pamela White (Cellular Sales) Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Choi, Esq., Chelsea Kim (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION

Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Notice of Supplemental Notice of Filing--Plaintiff's submission of Defendant's Exhibits 1-8 of Defendant's Opposition (paper no. 132)-- exhibits were referenced on paper no. 132 with Certificate of Service pursuant to Superior Court Rule 9A, FILED. Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Defendants Best Buy Stores L.P., Best Buy Co., Inc.'s Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Michael A. Grill (assented to), with Exhibit A Affidavit and Exhibit B Board of Bar Overseers', with Certificate of Service FILED Applies To: Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant); Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc., Best Buy Stores L.P. (Defendant)

Defendant Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Response to the Motions to Compel Arbitration With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Memorandum in opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction with Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Opposition to The Commissioner of Revenue's OPPOSITION to the Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction, FILED. filed by Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Affidavit of Compliance with Superior Court Rule 9A and Rule 9C With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party)

Reply/Sur-reply Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC's Reply in support of its Motion to Compel Individual Arbitrations of and stay plaintiffs Pixley's and Martin's claims, FILED. Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant) With Certificate of Service

Matthew Horvitz, Esq.Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Memorandum Memorandum of Law in support of Motion to Compel Individual arbitration of and stay plaintiffs Pixley's and Martin's claims with Certificate of Service and Exhibits 1-6, FILED. Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC's Motion to Compel Individual Arbitrations of and stay plaintiff Pixley's and Martin's claims with Certificate of Service and Certificate of Compliance with Superior Court Rule 9C, FILED. Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party)

Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Notice of of List of Documents filed: 1. Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction; 2. Plaintiffs' Memorandum of Law in support of motion for preliminary injunction; 3. Vendor Defendants' Opposition to plaintiffs' motion for preliminary injunction; 4. Supplement to vendor defendants' opposition submitted by defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC; 5. Plaintiffs' reply in support of motion for preliminary injunction; 6. Certificate of Conference; 7. Notice of Filing; 8. List of documents. With Certificate of Service. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Notice of Filing, With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Certificate of Service pursuant to Superior Court Rule 9A, With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Reply/Sur-reply Plaintiffs' reply in support of Motion for Preliminary Injunction, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Thomson, Esq., Matthew W (Attorney) on behalf of William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff) With Certificate of Service

Affidavit of James F. Martin, FILED. Applies To: Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Request for March 21, 2024 hearing date, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Opposition to Defendant Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC's Supplemental to Vendors' OPPOSITION to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction, With Certificate of Service, FILED. filed by Applies To: Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant); Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Statement of Corporate disclosure statement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Opposition to Defendant Bust Buy Stores, LP's, Best Buy Co., Inc.'s, Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's, Cellular Sales of Massachusetts, LLC's and AT&T Mobility LLC's OPPOSITION to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction, with Exhibits 1-8 and Certificate of Service, FILED. filed by Applies To: Julie R. Offerman Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); C. Larry Carbo III Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Maroney, Esq., Michael T (Attorney) on behalf of Best Buy Co., Inc. (Defendant); Horvitz, Esq., Matthew (Attorney) on behalf of Cellular Sales of Massachusetts LLC (Defendant)

Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Memorandum in support of plaintiffs' motion for Preliminary Injunction With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Plaintiff Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Harrington, Jr. Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, William Hillman Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Scott Martin Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated, Dan Cavanaugh Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated's Motion for Preliminary Injunction With Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Connor, Esq., John (Attorney) on behalf of Mayer Kahan Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Defendant Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue's Response to the motions to compel arbitration, FILED. Applies To: Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant); Randall, Esq., Roger H (Attorney) on behalf of Geoffrey E Snyder In his/her capacity Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Revenue (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Notice of Filing and list of documents. 1. Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings and request for hearing ("motion); 2. Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's memorandum in support of motion; 3. Exhibit 1 to motion, declaration of Lacy Kennedy, IV, in support of defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's motion, and Exhibits A through Q thereto; 4. Exhibit 2 to motion, tolling agreement; 5. Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Proposed Order; 6. Response by the Commissioner of Revenue to the motions to compel arbitration; 7. Plaintiffs' Opposition to defendants' motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings; 8. Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's reply in support of its motion; 9. Declaration of James F. Martin, in support of Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's reply in support of its motion, and Exhibit A thereto; 10. Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's Corporate Disclosure Statement; 11. Request for March 21, 2024 hearing date. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Reply/Sur-reply Cellco Partnership d/b/a/ Verizon Wireless's reply memorandum in support of motion to compel arbitration, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Opposition to Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendants' Motions to Compel arbitration and stay proceedings, FILED, filed by Applies To: Morneau, Esq., Jeffrey (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Donohue, Esq., Matthew Lucas (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff); Liss-Riordan, Esq., Shannon (Attorney) on behalf of Melissa Pixley Individually and in his/her capacity On behalf of all other persons similarly situated (Plaintiff)

Proposed Filings/Orders FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT M - eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT 2 - Tolling agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT L - eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT P - eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT Q - My Verizon Wireless customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT J - Verizon eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT K - eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT O - My Verizon Wireless customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT E - Verizon wireless order confirmation dated 10/28/15, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT N - My Verizon customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT D - Verizon wireless order confirmation dated 1/19/15, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT I - Verizon eConsent, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT C - Verizon order confirmation, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant) dated 12/4/13

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT H - Verizon Wireless customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT A - my verizon customer agreement, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT G - Verizon Wireless customer information overview, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT 1 -Declaration of Lacy Kennedy, IV, in support of Defendant Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings and request for hearing, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Defendant Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless's Motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings and request for hearing with Certification of Compliance with Rule 9C and Certificate of Service, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix EXHIBIT F - Verizon wireless order confirmation dated 9/9/16, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Thomas M Elcock, Esq.'s Memorandum in support of Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless's motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings, FILED. Applies To: Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant); Michael Ross Pro Hac Vice (Other interested party); Rakestraw, Ann H (Other interested party); Mueller, Rachel E (Other interested party); Elcock, Esq., Thomas M (Attorney) on behalf of Cellco Partnership Doing Business as Verizon Wireless (Defendant)

Exhibits/Appendix List of Documents, FILED. 1. AT&T Mobility LLC's motion to compel arbitration and to stay litigation; 2. Memo of law in support of AT&T's motion to compel; 3. Decl. of Jennifer K. Sharp in support of motion to compel; 1. Sharp Exhibits A-P; 4. Response by Commissioner of Revenue to vendors' motions to compel arbitration; 5. Plaintiffs' opposition to motion to compel arbitration; 6. AT&T's reply in support of motion to compel; 7. Supplemental decl. of Jennifer K. Sharp in support of reply; 1. Supplemental Sharp Exhibits A0C; and 8. AT&T Mobility LLC's corporate disclosure statement; 9. Notice of filing; and 10. List of Documents. Applies To: AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant); Jones Pro Hac Vice, Daniel E (Other interested party); Parasharami Pro Hac Vice, Archis A (Other interested party); Martin, Esq., James F (Attorney) on behalf of AT&T Mobility LLC (Defendant)

Attorney appearance electronically filed.