We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

FAIR , JAMES vs CONNORS , THERESA et al

A case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of St. Louis City, MO. Judge Timothy J. Wilson presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

December 03, 2013

Last Refreshed

September 30, 2022

Filing Location

St. Louis City, MO

Judge

Hon. Timothy J. Wilson Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Timothy J. Wilson   

Status

Trial Verdict

Parties

Plaintiffs

Fair , James

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Kleefuss , Kyle Anthony

Defendants

Mcneil , Scott
Connors , Theresa

Attorneys for Defendants

Madrid , Joseph Thomas
Clark , Arthur Frederick

Case Events

Type Description
Docket Event Judge/Clerk - Note
CASE TAXED
Docket Event Filing:
QUESTIONS AND JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Docket Event Filing:
JURY PANEL LIST, JURY PANEL QUESTIONAIRE
Docket Event Jury Verdict - Civil
ON THE CLAIM OF PLAINTIFF JAMES FAIR AGAINST DEFENDANT THERESA CONNORS, WE THE UNDERSIGNED JURORS, FIND IN FAVOR OF THERESA CONNORS.
Docket Event Certificate of Service
CERTIFICATE OF DEPOSITION OF DR. GURPREET PADDA WAS TAKEN ON NOVERMBER 3, 2015
Docket Event Order
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED THAT PLAINTIFF RECOVER NOTHING AGAINST DEFENDANT AND COSTS ARE ASSESSED AGAINST PLAINTIFF. SO ORDERED: JUDGE TIMOTHY WILSON #23161
Docket Event Trial Minutes Filed
CIVIL JURY TRIAL COURT RESUMES AT 10:16 A.M. TRIAL BEGAN. DEFENDANT DID NOT APPEAR. THERESA CONNORS CALL THE THE ATTONREY OFFICE STATED SHE CAN OT APPEAR IN COURT. TESTIMONY ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF BEGAN. COURT CALLS FOR MORNING RECESS. ADMONISION READ TO JURORS. COURT WILL BE IN TEMPORARY RECESS. COURT RESUMES AT 11:44 A.M. TESTIMONY ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF CONTINUES. COURT CALLS FOR LUNCHEON RECESS. ADMONISION READ TO JURORS. COURT WILL BE IN RECESS TILL 2:00 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT 2:10 P.M. TRIAL CONTINUES. ORAL MOTION FOR DRECTED VERDICT. DENIED OVERRULED. TESTIMONY ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT BEGAN AND CONCLUDED. COURT CALLS FOR TEMPORARY RECESS. ADMONISION READ TO JUROS. COURT WILL BE IN TEMPORARY RECESS. ORAL MOTION FOR DRECTED VERDICT-DENIED OVERRULED FOR PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT. COURT RESUMES AT 3:37 P.M. THE COURT READ THE FINAL INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY. FINAL ARGUMENT OF COUNSEL MADE. SWEARING OF SHERIFF. JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE AT 4:10 P.M. THE COURT DISCHARGES ALTERNATE JURORS. QUESTION(S) FROM JURORS AT 4:23 P.M. JURY RETURNS TO COURT AT 5:18 P.M. WITH A VERDICT AS FOLLOWS. IN FAVOR OF DEFENDANT THERESA CONNORS. WAIVED POLLING OF JURORS. VERDICT OF THE JURY ACCEPTED BY THE COURT AND ORDERED FILED TOGETHER WITH THE INSTRUCTIONS OF THE COURT. JURY DISCHARGED. AT 5:22 P.M. OFFER OF JUDGMENT FILED AND COPIES GIVEN TO PARTIES OF RECORD. COURT IS ADJOURNED AT 5:35 P.M. COURT REPORTER-RONALD PARKER C0773 SO ORDERED: JUDGE TIMOTHY WILSON #23161 PLAINTIFF REST THEIR CASE. PLAINTIFF TESTIMONY CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Filing:
JURY TRIAL REPORT
Docket Event Notice of Dismissal
COMES NOW, PLAINTIFF AND DISMISSES DEFENDANT SCOTT MCNEIL WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
Docket Event Jury Trial Conducted
Scheduled For: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM ; TIMOTHY J WILSON; Carnahan Courthouse
Docket Event Filing:
PRIOR INVOLVEMENT WITH LITIGATION AND CLAIMS/JUROR NON-DISCLOSURE
Docket Event Motion In Limine
DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE
Docket Event Trial Minutes Filed
CIVIL JURY TRIAL CAUSE CALLED. PLAINTIFF APPEARS IN PERSON AND BY ATTORNEY kYLE KLEEFUS #61738. DEFENDANT APPEAS AND BY ARTHUR CLARK #26983. COURT REPORTER-rONALD PARKER #C0773. PLAINTIFF FILE DISMISSAL ON DEFENDANT SCOTT MCNEIL. JURY PANEL OF 36 JURORS CALLED. JURY PANEL SWORN FOR VOIR DIRE. EXAMINATION OF THE JURY PAENL OF VOIR DIRE BEGAN. COURT CALLS FOR LUNCHEON RECESS. ADMONISION READ TO JURORS. COURT WILL BE IN RECESS TILL 1:30 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT 3:46 P.M. JURY OF TWELVE (12) WITH TWO (2) ALTERNATES JURORS SELECTED. JURY SWORN. INSTRUCTION M.A.I. 2.01 READ TO JURY. OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF BEGAN AND CONCLUDED. OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT BEGAN AND CONCLUDED. COURT CALLS FOR ADJOURNMENT FOR THE DAY. ADMONISION READ TO JURORS. COURT WILL BE IN RECESS TILL TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 2015 AT 9:00 A.M. JURORS ADMONISHED FOR THE DAY. COURT REPORTER-RONALD PARKER #0773 SO ORDERED: JUDGE TIMOTHY WILSON #23161
Docket Event Motion In Limine
PLAINTIFF'S MOTIONS IN LIMINE
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 11/16/2015 - Jury Trial Conducted \n Scheduled For: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM ; TIMOTHY J WILSON; Carnahan Courthouse
Docket Event Judge Assigned
Docket Event Order for Change of Judge
Filed By: JULIAN BUSH
Docket Event Ord Transfer P/Judge for Assn
Cause re assigned to Division # 23 for trial on 11/16/15. So Ordered: Bryan Hettenbach, Judge
Docket Event Motion for Change of Judge; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS
hearing Notice of Hearing Filed
Notice of Hearing; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Motion In Limine
Defendant's Motion In Limine; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS, SCOTT MCNEIL
Docket Event Order
THIS MATTER COMES TO BE HEARD ON SCOTT MCNEIL'S MOTIONFOR GOOD FAITH FINDING AS THE CLAIM OF JAMES FAIR AGAIST HIM. DUE NOTICE HAVING BEEN GIVEN AND THE COURT BEING FULLY ADVISED IN THE PREMISES, THIS COURT FINDS THAT THE SETTLEMENT REACHED BETWEEN DEFENDANT SCOTT MCNEIL AND PLAINTIFF JAMES FAIR IS IN GOOD FAITH WITHIN THE MEANING OF SECTION 537.060 RSMo AND SCOTT MCNEIL'S MOTION FOR GOOD FAITH FINDING IS GRANTED, WITHOUT OBJECTION. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT ALL PRESENT AND FUTURE CONTRIBUTION CLAIMS AGAINST DEFENDANT SCOTT MCNEIL AS THE PERTAIN TO CLAIMS OF JAMES FAIR AND FOREVER BARRED. SO ORDERED JUDGE DAVID DOWD #32929
Docket Event Amended Answer Filed
First Amended Answer; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK
Docket Event Motion Filed
Motion for Good Faith Finding; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: JOSEPH THOMAS MADRID \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Notice to Take Deposition of Dr Gurpreet Padda on November 3,2015 at 5pm; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Notice to Take Deposition of Gurpreet Padda on November 3,2015 at 5pm; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Pluries Summons Issued
Document ID: 15-SMOS-7084, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Order - Special Process Server
Docket Event Motion Special Process Server
Motion to Appoint Special Process Server; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Pluries Summons Requested
Request for Pluries Summons; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS
hearing Hearing/Trial Cancelled
Scheduled For: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM ; BRYAN L HETTENBACH; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 11/13/2015 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM ; JULIAN BUSH; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Judge Assigned
Docket Event Ord Transfer P/Judge for Assn
CAUSE ASSIGNED TO DIVISION #04 FOR TRIAL ON NOVEMBER 16, 2015. SO ORDERED: BRYAN L. HETTENBACH, JUDGE
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 10/22/2015 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled \n Scheduled For: 11/16/2015; 9:00 AM ; BRYAN L HETTENBACH; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Judge Assigned
Docket Event Motion Granted/Sustained
BY AGREEMENT OF ALL COUNSEL, DEFENDANT MCNEIL'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE IS CALLED AND GRANTED. SERVICE ON MCNEIL ON MAY 31,2015 IS QUASHED AND HELD INVALID. SUMMONS ON MCNEIL TO BE REISSUED AT REQUEST OF PLAINTIFF. SO ORDERED: JUDGE BRYAN HETTENBACH
hearing Hearing/Trial Cancelled
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 08/10/2015; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Order for Continuance
JOINT Motion for Continuance WAS CALLED, HEARD AND GRANTED. SO ORDERED: BRYAN L. HETTENBACH, JUDGE
Docket Event Request for Jury Trial Filed
Filed By: JOSEPH THOMAS MADRID
Docket Event Entry of Appearance Filed
Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: JOSEPH THOMAS MADRID
Docket Event Motion to Quash Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: JOSEPH THOMAS MADRID \n On Behalf Of: SCOTT MCNEIL
Docket Event Judge Assigned
Docket Event Ord Transfer P/Judge for Assn
Cause assigned to Division # 04 for trial on 08/10/15. So Ordered: Bryan Hettenbach, Judge
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 08/10/2015 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 08/10/2015; 9:00 AM ; JULIAN BUSH; City of St. Louis
hearing Hearing/Trial Cancelled
Scheduled For: 08/10/2015; 9:00 AM ; BRYAN L HETTENBACH; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Notice of Service
SERVICE RETURN AS TO SCOTT MCNEIL; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Family Member/Roommate Served
Document ID - 15-SMCC-13619; Served To - MCNEIL, SCOTT; Server - ; Served Date - 31-MAY-15; Served Time - 15:12:00; Service Type - Special Process Server; Reason Description - Served
Docket Event Pluries Summons Issued
Document ID: 15-SMCC-13619, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Pluries Summons Requested
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT SUMMONS SHALL ISSUE FOR SERVICE UPON DEFENDANT SCOTT MCNEIL BY SPECIAL PROCESS SERVER IN ACCORDANCE WITH PLAINTIFF'S REQUEST FOR PLURIES SUMMONS E-FILED ON 4/23/15 AND PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SPECIAL PROCESS SERVER, E-FILED AND ORDERED ON 4/23/15. SO ORDERED: JUDGE BRYAN HETTENBACH
Docket Event Order - Special Process Server
Docket Event Pluries Summons Requested
Request for Pluries Summons; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS
Docket Event Motion Special Process Server
Motion to Appoint Special Process Server; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Summons Returned Non-Est
Document ID - 15-SMCC-2433; Served To - MCNEIL, SCOTT; Server - ; Served Date - 05-APR-15; Served Time - 00:00:00; Service Type - Sheriff Department; Reason Description - Non-est
Docket Event Pluries Summons Issued
Document ID: 15-SMCC-2433, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Pluries Summons Requested
Request for Pluries Summons; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Notice to Take Deposition
Notice of Deposition of Marvin Mishkin on April 8,2015 at 1pm; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
Docket Event Notice To Take Deposition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
Docket Event Cert Serv Answers Interrog Fil
Cert of Serv Def 1st Amnd Ans to Pltf Rogs EXPERT DISCLOSURE; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
Docket Event Note to Clerk eFiling
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK
Docket Event Cert Serv Answers Interrog Fil
Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Filing:
certificate of officer and statement of deposition charges
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 07/16/2015 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled \n Scheduled For: 08/10/2015; 9:00 AM ; BRYAN L HETTENBACH; City of St. Louis
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 01/20/2015; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 11/17/2014; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 12/15/2014 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 01/20/2015; 9:00 AM ; PHILIP HEAGNEY; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Notice to Take Deposition of Theresa Conners; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Summons Returned Non-Est
Document ID - 14-SMOS-7690; Served To - MCNEIL, SCOTT; Server - ; Served Date - 07-NOV-14; Served Time - 00:00:00; Service Type - Sheriff Department; Reason Description - Moved
Docket Event Pluries Summons Issued
Document ID: 14-SMOS-7690, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Pluries Summons Requested
Request for Pluries Summons; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 09/29/2014; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 11/17/2014 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 11/17/2014; 9:00 AM ; PHILIP HEAGNEY; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Notice to Take Deposition
Notice of Deposition of James Fair on November 14,2014 at 10am; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 08/04/2014; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 09/29/2014 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 09/29/2014; 9:00 AM ; PHILIP HEAGNEY; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 08/04/2014 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 08/04/2014; 9:00 AM ; PHILIP HEAGNEY; City of St. Louis
hearing Hearing Continued/Rescheduled
Hearing Continued From: 06/16/2014; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
Docket Event Summons Returned Non-Est
Document ID - 14-SMOS-1328; Served To - MCNEIL, SCOTT; Server - ; Served Date - 26-MAR-14; Served Time - 07:34:00; Service Type - Sheriff Department; Reason Description - Non-est
Docket Event Alias Summons Issued
Document ID: 14-SMOS-1328, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Alias Summons Requested
Request for Alias Summons; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Cert Serv Answers Interrog Fil
Cert of Mail Def Ans to Pltf Rogs and RFP; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
Docket Event Note to Clerk eFiling
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK
Docket Event Cert Serv Answers Interrog Fil
Certificate of Service - Plaintiffs Responses to Defendant Conners First Discovery; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Answer Filed
Answer of Connors; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK
Docket Event Entry of Appearance Filed
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK
Docket Event Cert Serv of Interrog Filed
Certificate of Service - Plaintiff s First Discovery to Defendant Conners.
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS \n On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Cert Serv of Interrog Filed
Filed By: ARTHUR FREDERICK CLARK \n On Behalf Of: THERESA CONNORS
Docket Event Family Member/Roommate Served
Document ID - 13-SMCC-23002; Served To - CONNORS, THERESA; Server - ; Served Date - 24-DEC-13; Served Time - 00:00:00; Service Type - Sheriff Department; Reason Description - Served
Docket Event Jury Trial Scheduled
Associated Entries: 06/16/2014 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled \n Scheduled For: 06/16/2014; 9:00 AM ; PHILIP HEAGNEY; City of St. Louis
Docket Event Summons Returned Non-Est
Document ID - 13-SMOS-6432; Served To - MCNEIL, SCOTT; Server - ; Served Date - 10-DEC-13; Served Time - 00:00:00; Service Type - Sheriff Department; Reason Description - Non-est
Docket Event Filing Info Sheet eFiling
Filed By: KYLE ANTHONY KLEEFUSS
Docket Event Pet Filed in Circuit Ct
Petition.
On Behalf Of: JAMES FAIR
Docket Event Judge Assigned
Docket Event Summons Issued-Circuit
Document ID: 13-SMOS-6432, for MCNEIL, SCOTT.
Docket Event Summons Issued-Circuit
Document ID: 13-SMCC-23002, for CONNORS, THERESA.

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue