Preview
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
Superior Court - Worcester &
E-FILED
Docket Number
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS:
WORCESTER, ss. SUPEIOR:‘COURT DEPARTMENT
CIVIL ACTION NO. SEN NAG
MAUREEN CONNOLLY )
Plaintiff, )
)
V. )
CHUBB INSURANCE COMPANY }
OF NEW JERSEY )
Defendant )
)
AFFIDAVIT IN suPrORTOF APPLICATION COMPELLING DEPOSITION
OF DAVID RAVENELLE IN THE COMMONWEALTH
FOR.A PROCEEDING IN A TRIBUNAL-OUTSIDE THE COMMONWEALTH
PURSUANT TO MGL, c. 223A, s. 11.and MGL c. 223, 8. 45 YAY
1, ANDREW D. NEBENZAHL, on oath depose and state:
1. Taman attorney licensed to practice in thé Commonwealth of. Massachusetts,
2. My office is located at One Post Office Square, Sharon, MA 02067.
3. There is ati action now pending before the Superior Court of New Jersey Law
Division ~ Monmouth County, New Jersey, entitled Maureen L, Connolly. Chubb
Insurance Comp
of any
New:Jersey, Docket No. MON=L-2095-22 (“New Jersey
Action”),
Tam.acting at the request of and.on behalf of Harris $. Feldman, Esq., ID No.
010712003, of Blume, Forte Fried, Zerres & Molinari, a Professional Corporation,
One Main Stiect, Chatham, New Jersey, 37402, the atlomey of record in the New
Jersey Action.
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
‘Superior Court - Worcester
Docket Number
The Superior Court of New Jersey Law Division: Monmouth County; New Jersey
issued.a Commission for the out-of-state deposition of the witness named David
Ravenelle.
A copy of the Order to Take Deposition Outside: of New Jersey for David Ravenelie.
and.a Subpoena Ad Testificandum and Subpoena Duces Tecum are attached heréto.
Upon Order of this Court, New Jersey Counsel advises he will serve David Ravenelle
the attached Subpoena Ad Testificandum and Subpoena Duces Tecum, the New
Jersey Order and this Court’s Order at his hore address in North Oxford,
Massachusetts.
The testimony and documents sought of. David Ravenelle are rélevant, material and
necessaty to the issues involved in the above-described New Jersey action.
Under the law of New Jersey, records and testimony obtained pursuant to subpoena
may be used in the New Jersey action.
SIGNED UNDER THE PAINS AND PENALTIES OF PERJURY THIS ott DAY OF
Jew why L_, 2023.
vy
ANDREWD.:EBENZATT :
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
Superior Court - Worcester MON-L-002095-22
Docket Number 10/06/2023 Pg1of2 Trans ID: LCV20233060350
BLUME, FORTE, FRIED, ZERRES & MOLINARI
A Professional Corporation. FILED
Harris $, Feldman, Esq. IATTORNEY 1D NO.:
010712003) October 6, 2023
Oné Main Street
Ctiatham, New Jersey 07928:
(973) 635-5400 RICHARD W. ENGLISH,
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MAUREEN CONNOLLY,
Plaintiff, SUPERIOR courr OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION; MONMOUTH COUNTY
Vv
DOCKET NO.: MON-L-2095-22
CHUBB INSURANGE COMPANY oF NEW Civil Action
JERSEY,
ORDER
_ Defendants.
This matter having been opened to the
Gourt by Blume, Forté, Fried, Zerres
& Molinari, P.C., attorneys for Plaintiff, Maureen Conno
lly (‘plaintiff }, and-upon
due. notice fo all counsel of record, and the Court having considered and
reviewed the moving papers: and
For good cause shown;
Itis‘on this 6™ day of October, 2023
ORDERED that Plaintiff's application for eniry of an Order
authorizing the
Clerk of the Superior Court of New Jersey to issue
a Commission for. the. out. Hof-
state deposition of the witness named David Ravenellé,
at a location convenient
to thé witness in the State of Massachusetts, be and:is
hereby granted; and it is
further
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
‘Superior Court - Worcester
Docket Number MON-L-002005-22 10/06/2023 Pg2of2 Trans ID: LCV20233060359
ORDERED ‘that the Commission, which will be if the form of Exhibit A
annexed to Plaintiff's attorney's moving papers,
will request that the Clerk of the
appro} pridte Court ofthe State of Massachusett
s; having jurisdiction to honor New
Jersey commissions for deposition subpoena
s, issue a subpoend duces tecum oO
subpeena ad Téstificandum for the conduct of
a deposition of David Ravenelle
at areasonable location in that jurialietion
‘and in accordancwith
e the custom,
practice, court rules, and procédures of that
jurisdiction; and it is further
ORDERED that the language of the Commission will
Mention that Plaintitt’s
attorneys wish to réserve the right to make a video técor
d of the deposition for
potential use at time of trial; and it is further
ORDERED that Plaintiff's attorneys will present a Copy
of this Order to. the
Office of the Cletk 6f the Supetior Court of New Jefsey,
along with thé proposed
form of Commission, and the ‘Clerk. or the Clerk's Deput
y Clerk will sign and affix.
Gold Seal'to the Commission in the for indicated withou
t thé néeéd for further
Order of this: Court: and tt ks further
ORDERED that service of this Order shall be deemed
effectucted upon: all
parties: Upon upload to-eCourts,
EO
Richard W. English —
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
‘Superior Court - Worcester
Docket Number
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
ONE MAIN STREET
JOHN.M. BLUME,
(09322020
‘DAVID M- FRIED-¢.
a 2 a an CHATHAM; NEW JERSEY 07928
WWWNIATTY.COM
CAROL-L.-FORTE # VA AOAC a RINTVU
MICHAEL
B. ZERRES'+ (973) 635.5400
JOHN-E. MOLINAR I FAX: 073) 635-9339
‘MITCHELL. J. MAKOWICZ, JR.-¢
JEFFREY
J. ZENNA #
‘A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
KENNETH W.ELWOOD +
HARRISS: «
RICHARD J. VILLANOVA'¢
NORBERTO A: GARCIA®
ABRAHAMN. MILGRAUM
ROBIN A.. DONATO
CONNOR C. TURPAN’
BRIAN. RIEHL OTHER OFFICES:
RICHARD T. MADURSKI JERSEY CITY, NI 07306
TERRENCEJ. HULL NORTH BERGEN, NJ 07047
October 13, 2023 ‘SEA.GIRT, NI:08750:
OF Counsel
RONALD P..GOLDFADEN 4
CYNTHIA M. CRAIG
BRIAN E. MAHONEY
by io Sabreme, Court of
tigate vil Teal torte.
Via Process Server
David Ravenelle
5 Marcam Village
North Oxford, MA 01537
Re: Connolly v. Chubb Insurance Company
Docket No.: MON-L-2095-22
Our File No.: 2301391
Dear Mr. Ravenelle:
Enclosed herewith please find 4 Sub poena Ad Testificandum with.regard
to the
above captioned miatter. Kindly comph ly with this Subpoena ‘to appear remotely
via
Zoom on November 30, 2023 at 10:00 A.M. for your deposition orn the dltetnat
ive,.be
subject to Court sanctions. Please be advised that this de position will be videotaped
pursuant to Rule.4:14-9(b).
Should you have any questions or should the date and time be: inconvenient,
please do not hesitate te call me. and | will bé happy to reschedule. KINDLY’ CALL MY
OFFICE THE DAY BEFORE TO. CONFIRM. YOUR DEPOSITION.
H RRIS S. FELDMAN
HSF/nh .
6¢: Veritext, Court Reporting
arah Hamiel-Davis, Esq.
Michael Zigelman, Esq..
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
Superior Court - Worcester
Docket Number
BLUME, FORTE FRIED, ZERRES & MOLINARI
A Professional Corporation
One Main Street
Chatham, New Jersey 07928.
(973) 635-5400
Attorneys for Plaintiff
By: Harris$. Feldman. Esq. ID No: 010712003
MAUREEN be CONNOLLY . SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION - MONMOUTH COUNTY
Plaintiff, DOCKET NO.: MON+L-2095-22
VS.
Civil Action
CHUBB INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW
AERSEY SUBPOENA AD TESTIFICANDUM.
‘Defendants. SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY TO: David Ravenelle
5 Maream Village
Notth Oxford, MA 01537
YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED fo appear remotely via'Zoom before the
Superior Court of New Jersey, ‘Civil Division, Monmouth County. on behalf of the.
Plaintiff Part, on November 30 at 10:00 .a:m..and there to testify asa witness in
:
the above-captioned matter.
YOU ARE.ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you and to produce at that time the
following described books, papers, documents and other tangible things:
1 To produce.any materials or documents: you have related to a matter
called “Maureen Connolly v. Douglass R. Simons, et al., Docket No.: MON-L+
2598-22", and to provide. swam testimony at deposition
Provided thatif you are notified: that a motion to quash the subpoena has been
filed, the subpoenaed evidence shall not be produced or released until ordered
fo do'so by the court of the release is consented to by all parties to the action.
Date Filed 11/6/2023 12:16 PM
‘Superior Court - Worcester
Docket Number
Failure to, appear or comply with the command of this Subpoena will subject
you to the penalties provided by law.
Dated October 13, 2023 /s/Michelle M. Smith
Michelle M. Smith; Clerk of the Superior Court