On May 31, 1978 a
was filed
involving a dispute between
Muirhead, Sharon,
and
Universal Property And Casualty Company,
for CIRCUIT CIVIL
in the District Court of Osceola County.
Preview
Filing # 190009935 E-Filed 01/18/2024 11:52:32 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA
SHARON MUIRHEAD,
Plaintiff, CASE NO: 2021-CC-3232-CI
v.
UNIVERSAL PROPERTY AND
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
a Florida corporation,
Defendant.
________________________________/
PLAINTIFF’S REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT
COMES NOW Plaintiff, SHARON MUIRHEAD, by and through the undersigned
counsel and pursuant to Rule 1.370 of the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, and hereby files
and submits to Defendant, UNIVERSAL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY, the following requests for admissions and requests that Defendant admit to or
deny the following in writing, within thirty (30) days of the service of the Complaint herein:
1. Admit that the time sheet attached as Exhibit A, was provided in response to Plaintiff request
for documents seeking documents reflecting time spent by counsel on the above captioned
matter on behalf of Defendant.
RESPONSE:
2. Admit that Exhibit A, attached hereto, does not reflect all time spent by attorneys in the above
captioned matter on behalf of Defendant.
RESPONSE:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY the foregoing document was electronically filed with the Clerk of
the Court by using the Florida Courts E-filing Portal system which will send a copy to all
counsel of record on this the 18th day of January, 2024.
MAPP & PARKER, P.A.
/s/ Charles Parker Jr./
Charles Parker, Jr., Esquire
Florida Bar #850322
Email: capjnp@gmail.com
Charles Parker, III, Esquire
Florida Bar #1014981
Email: caparker1419@gmail.com
Alt. Email: gwiker1419@gmail.com
1419 East Robinson Street
Orlando, Florida 32801
(407) 894-1285
Attorneys for Plaintiff
2
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Laura Rodriguez 1/10/2022 Draft and file NOA 0.1 $75.00
Cody Ingalls 1/19/2022 Review claim file and draft Defendant's Answer and Affirmative Defenses 1 $225.00
Stephanie Lopez
Rivera 1/31/2022 Review file and draft Defendant's discovery responses 3 $75.00
Cody Ingalls 2/10/2022 Finalize Defendant's discovery responses 0.5 $225.00
Stephanie Lopez
Rivera 2/17/2022 serve Defendant's discovery responses and e-file notice of compliance 0.1 $75.00
Laura Rodriguez 2/21/2022 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of PL 0.2 $75.00
Cody Ingalls 2/21/2022 Review PL's NOTD Duces Tecum of Defendant's CR 0.2 $225.00
Cody Ingalls 8/16/2022 Review Plaintiff's Notice for Trial 0.1 $225.00
Cody Ingalls 8/16/2022 Review PL's Ntc for Trial 0.1 $75.00
Cody Ingalls 11/8/2022 Review Trial Order 0.1 $225.00
Laura Rodriguez 11/8/2022 Calculate deadlines and calendar trial order 0.5 $75.00
Cody Ingalls 12/15/2022 Review Notice of Mediation 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 3/7/2023 Draft and file Amended NOA 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 3/16/2023 Review PL's NOTD of FA 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 3/16/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Def's FA 0.1 $225.00
Draft Defendant's Expert Interrogatories and Expert Request to Produce to
Becky Ventura 4/4/2023 Plaintiff 0.5 $75.00
Email exchange with oc re: inspection and PL's objections to same; review file
Becky Ventura 4/5/2023 and draft Defendant's Motion for Entry Upon Land 0.5 $75.00
Alex Perez 4/5/2023 Review and finalize Defendant's Expert Discovery Requests to Plaintiff 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/11/2023 Review PL's expert witness disclosure 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 4/13/2023 Draft Defendant's Expert Witness Disclosure 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Review and finalize Defendant's Expert Witness Disclosure 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 4/13/2023 Draft Notice of Unavailability 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Review and finalize Notice of Unavailability 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 4/13/2023 Draft Defendant's Mt for Entry Upon Land and compile exhibits 0.5 $75.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Finalize Defendant's Mt for Entry 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/19/2023 Review Plaintiff's NPNP 0.2 $225.00
Becky Ventura 4/20/2023 Draft Defendant's Objection to Plaintiff's NPNP 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 4/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Entry Upon Land 0.7 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/24/2023 Review Plaintiff's Witness and Exhibit List 0.6 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Finalize Defendant's Objection to NPNP 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Review Plaintiff's Notice of Hearing on Defendant's Motion for Entry 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Review Plaintiff's NOH on Plaintiff's NPNP 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/27/2023 Review Pl's Answers to Expert Interrogatories 0.8 $225.00
Alex Perez 4/27/2023 Review PL's Responses to Expert RP 0.6 $225.00
Becky Ventura 4/28/2023 Draft Defendant's Witness and Exhibit List 0.6 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/4/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on Def's Objection to PL's NPNP 0.1 $225.00
Draft Defendant's Notice of Serving PFS and Proposal for Settlement to
Becky Ventura 5/10/2023 Plaintiff 0.8 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Finalize Defendant's PFS to PL 0.3 $225.00
Draft Defendant's Motion for Leave to Amend AAD and proposed Amended
Becky Ventura 5/10/2023 AAD 0.6 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Finalize Def's Mt for Leave to Amend Answer and Affirmative Defenses 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Review Order Overruling Objections to PL's NPNP 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Review Order Denying Def's MTC 0.2 $225.00
Review file and draft Defendant's Response to PL's MSJ as to 1st Affirmative
Alex Perez 5/15/2023 Defense 2 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/17/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MSJ 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 5/17/2023 RR email from oc re: deposition of William Clemons 0.1 $75.00
Review PL's NOH on PL's MTC Compliance w/Court Order, MTC Depo of
Alex Perez 5/18/2023 William Clemmons, and Def's Mt for Leave to Amend 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.2 $225.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of Mediation 0.1 $225.00
Email exchange with oc re: hearings on Defendant's Mt for Leave, and PL's
Heather Payne 5/18/2023 MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.3 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/22/2023 Review PL's Response in Opposition to Def's Mt for Leave to Amend 0.8 $225.00
Becky Ventura 5/24/2023 Email to oc enclosing 2015 claim information 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/25/2023 Review PL's NOTD of William Clemmons 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 5/25/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 5/25/2023 Draft Order on Def's Mt for Leave 0.2 $75.00
Heather Payne 5/25/2023 Email exchange with oc re: FA depo 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 5/30/2023 Review PL's Mt for Leave to File Amended W&E List (with Amended W&E List) 0.5 $225.00
Email exchange with oc re: PL's Mt for Leave to Amend Witness and Exhibit
Alex Perez 5/30/2023 List 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 6/6/2023 email exchange with oc re: scheduling deposition of Jill Clement 0.3 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/7/2023 Review PL's Amended NOTD Duces Tecum of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 6/8/2023 Email exchange with oc re: deposition of Defendant's expert 0.2 $75.00
Review file and draft Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's MSJ as to 2nd
Alex Perez 6/9/2023 Affirmative Defense 2.5 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/14/2023 Review PL's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/15/2023 Review PL's Notice of Service of Mt for Sanctions 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/15/2023 Review PL's 3rd set of Interrogatories 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/16/2023 Review PL's 2nd RP 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Def's CR 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's MSJ as to Def's 3rd Affirmative Defense 1.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review Amended Ntc of Mediation 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's Mt to Strike Def's Mt for Leave to Amend AAD 0.6 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review Order on PL's MTC Compliance w/Court Order 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review order on PL's MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.1 $225.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Heather Payne 6/19/2023 email to oc re: mediation 0.1 $75.00
Review claim file, review Plaintiff's deposition transcript, and begin drafting
Becky Ventura 6/20/2023 outline for Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 1 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's notice of hearing on Plaintiff's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of Depo of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review Ntc of Cancellation of Depo of CR 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Draft Defendant's MIL re: PL's Witnesses 1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 6/21/2023 Draft Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. 3.5 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/21/2023 Review PL's 4th Interrogatories to Def 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/21/2023 Review PL's 2nd RA to Def 0.3 $225.00
Becky Ventura 6/22/2023 Review draft MSJ with atty. 0.3 $75.00
Becky Ventura 6/23/2023 Begin compiling trial exhibits. 1 $75.00
Becky Ventura 6/23/2023 Review file and draft Defendant's Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses. 0.6 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/26/2023 Review Plaintiff's Ntc of Cancellation of hearing on MSJ 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 6/26/2023 Draft Affidavit of CR in support of Def's MSJ; compile exhibits to MSJ. 0.4 $75.00
Becky Ventura 6/26/2023 Prepare mediation folder. 0.9 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/26/2023 RR PL's proposed Joint Pre-Trial Statement 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/27/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MIL re: damages 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Draft Defendant's Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories. 0.6 $75.00
Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Email to oc re: proposed Agreed Order on PL's MTC Answers to 2nd Rogs (x3) 0.2 $75.00
Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Prepare hearing folder for 6/29 hearing on PL's MTC answers to 2nd rogs. 0.3 $75.00
Draft and file Defendant's Notice of Compliance re: Defendant's Answers to
Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $75.00
Email exchange w/oc re: unilaterally set hearings on Plaintiff's motions in
Becky Ventura 6/29/2023 limine. 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 6/29/2023 Review Joint Pre-Trial Statement 0.5 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/30/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on PL's MIL re: Damages 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 6/30/2023 Review mediation disposition report 0.1 $225.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 finalize and file MSJ 0.7 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/12/2023 Finalize Defendant's MSJ 1.1 $225.00
Draft and File Notice of Filing Transcript of Sharon Muirhead's Depo in Support
Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 of Def's MSJ 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/12/2023 Finalize affidavit of CR 0.2 $225.00
Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 Draft and file Ntc of Filing CR Affidavit 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/12/2023 email exchange with oc re: CMC 0.4 $225.00
Becky Ventura 7/17/2023 Draft Defendant's Mt for Continuance 0.8 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/17/2023 Finalize Defendant's Mt for Continuance 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 7/19/2023 Review PL's MTCBA to PL's 2nd Set of Interrogatories 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 7/19/2023 Review PL's MTC Discovery Responses 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 7/20/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MTC Disco Responses 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 7/21/2023 Draft and file NOH on Def's Mt for Continuance 0.2 $75.00
Becky Ventura 7/21/2023 Draft Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff's 2nd Request for Admissions 0.5 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/21/2023 Finalize Defendant's Responses to PL's 2nd RA 0.2 $225.00
Becky Ventura 7/21/2023 Draft Def's Responses to PL's 2nd RP 0.3 $75.00
Alex Perez 7/21/2023 Finalize Defendant's Responses to PL's 2nd RP 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 7/26/2023 Review Order Denying Def's Mt to Continue 0.2 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/1/2023 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MTCBA to 2nd set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of hearing on MSJ 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Draft Defendant's answers to PL's 3rd Interrogatories 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Finalize Defendant's answers to PL's 3rd Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Draft Defendant's answers to PL's 4th set of Interrogatories 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Finalize Defendant's answers to PL's 4th set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Draft Defendant's Amended Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of
Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Interrogatories 0.6 $75.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Finalize Defendant's Amended Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of
Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Interrogatories 0.2 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/3/2023 Draft and file Notice of Cancellation of Depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 2nd Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 3rd Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 4th Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/3/2023 email exchange with oc re: depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/10/2023 Draft and file re-notice of taking depo duces tecum of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/11/2023 Review verified return of non service re: PA 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 8/11/2023 email exchange with oc re: updated depo of PL 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/14/2023 Review Order on PL's MIL re: Damages 0.2 $225.00
Becky Ventura 8/14/2023 Draft Defendant's Motion to Compel Depo or Mt to Strike PL's Expert 0.5 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/15/2023 Finalize Defendant's Motion to Compel Depo or Mt to Strike PL's Expert 0.2 $225.00
Becky Ventura 8/15/2023 Draft Defendant's MTC PL's Continued Depo and Mt for Sanctions 0.8 $75.00
Heather Payne 8/16/2023 Draft and file NOH on Def's MTC Depo/Motion to Strike Pl's Expert 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/16/2023 Prepare for deposition of Destiny Muirhead 2 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/17/2023 Attend depo of Destiny Muirhead 1 $225.00
Draft and file amended NOH on MTC Depo of Expert and MTC PL's Continued
Heather Payne 8/18/2023 Depo 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/18/2023 Finalize Def's MTC PL's Continued Depo and Mt for Sanctions 0.2 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/20/2023 Review PL's Cross Notice of Hearing on Def's MTC Second Depo of PL 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/20/2023 Review PL's Response to Def's MTC Depo 0.3 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/21/2023 Review CNA of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/21/2023 email exchange with oc re: depo of PL 0.5 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/22/2023 Review Plaintiff's Objections to Duces Tecum requesdt re: depo of Plaintiff 0.5 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/22/2023 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of Anthony Jaffa 0.3 $75.00
Heather Payne 8/22/2023 Draft and file Def's 2nd Re-Notice of Taking Depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/22/2023 Review PL's Mt to Strike Def's Expert Witness List 0.2 $225.00
Exhibit A
Time
Personnel Date Description spent Rate
Review PL's Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum of Defendant's Expert,
Alex Perez 8/23/2023 Daniel Cross 0.3 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/23/2023 Draft NOTD Duces Tecum of RC of Grove Construction 0.2 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/23/2023 Review file and prepare for second deposition of Destiny Muirhead 3 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/24/2023 attend 2nd depo of Sharon Muirhead 1 $225.00
Draft and file Def's 4th Re-Notice of Taking Depo Duces Tecum of Destiny
Heather Payne 8/25/2023 Muirhead 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/25/2023 Review file and prepare for deposition of Destiny Muirhead 2 $225.00
Heather Payne 8/25/2023 RR email from oc re: trial docket 0.1 $75.00
Alex Perez 8/26/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Settlement 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 8/26/2023 Attend depo of Destiny Muirhead 1 $225.00
Alex Perez 11/27/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's Mt for Interest 0.1 $225.00
Alex Perez 12/6/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on PL's Mt for Interest and PL's Mt for Sanctions 0.1 $225.00
Becky Ventura 12/7/2023 Begin drafting Defendant's Amended Responses to Attorney Fee Discovery. 0.2 $75.00
1/10/2022 -
Laura Rodriguez 02/15/23 email exchange with oc re: scheduling PL's depo 0.7 $75.00
4/13/2023 -
Heather Payne 4/24/23 email exchange with oc re: hearing on Def's MTC Entry 0.4 $75.00
5/12/23 -
Heather Payne 5/15/23 email exchange with oc re: hearing on MSJ 0.3 $75.00
6/26/2023 -
Alex Perez 6/27/23 email exchange with oc re: joint pre-trial statement and exhibit exchange 0.4 $225.00
7/26/2023
Alex Perez 7/27/23 email exchange with oc re: deposition of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $225.00
Exhibit A
Document Filed Date
January 09, 2024
Case Filing Date
May 31, 1978
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
Filing # 190009935 E-Filed 01/18/2024 11:52:32 AM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA SHARON MUIRHEAD, Plaintiff, CASE NO: 2021-CC-3232-CI v. UNIVERSAL PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY a Florida corporation, Defendant. ________________________________/ PLAINTIFF’S REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT COMES NOW Plaintiff, SHARON MUIRHEAD, by and through the undersigned counsel and pursuant to Rule 1.370 of the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, and hereby files and submits to Defendant, UNIVERSAL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, the following requests for admissions and requests that Defendant admit to or deny the following in writing, within thirty (30) days of the service of the Complaint herein: 1. Admit that the time sheet attached as Exhibit A, was provided in response to Plaintiff request for documents seeking documents reflecting time spent by counsel on the above captioned matter on behalf of Defendant. RESPONSE: 2. Admit that Exhibit A, attached hereto, does not reflect all time spent by attorneys in the above captioned matter on behalf of Defendant. RESPONSE: CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY the foregoing document was electronically filed with the Clerk of the Court by using the Florida Courts E-filing Portal system which will send a copy to all counsel of record on this the 18th day of January, 2024. MAPP & PARKER, P.A. /s/ Charles Parker Jr./ Charles Parker, Jr., Esquire Florida Bar #850322 Email: capjnp@gmail.com Charles Parker, III, Esquire Florida Bar #1014981 Email: caparker1419@gmail.com Alt. Email: gwiker1419@gmail.com 1419 East Robinson Street Orlando, Florida 32801 (407) 894-1285 Attorneys for Plaintiff 2 Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Laura Rodriguez 1/10/2022 Draft and file NOA 0.1 $75.00 Cody Ingalls 1/19/2022 Review claim file and draft Defendant's Answer and Affirmative Defenses 1 $225.00 Stephanie Lopez Rivera 1/31/2022 Review file and draft Defendant's discovery responses 3 $75.00 Cody Ingalls 2/10/2022 Finalize Defendant's discovery responses 0.5 $225.00 Stephanie Lopez Rivera 2/17/2022 serve Defendant's discovery responses and e-file notice of compliance 0.1 $75.00 Laura Rodriguez 2/21/2022 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of PL 0.2 $75.00 Cody Ingalls 2/21/2022 Review PL's NOTD Duces Tecum of Defendant's CR 0.2 $225.00 Cody Ingalls 8/16/2022 Review Plaintiff's Notice for Trial 0.1 $225.00 Cody Ingalls 8/16/2022 Review PL's Ntc for Trial 0.1 $75.00 Cody Ingalls 11/8/2022 Review Trial Order 0.1 $225.00 Laura Rodriguez 11/8/2022 Calculate deadlines and calendar trial order 0.5 $75.00 Cody Ingalls 12/15/2022 Review Notice of Mediation 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 3/7/2023 Draft and file Amended NOA 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 3/16/2023 Review PL's NOTD of FA 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 3/16/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Def's FA 0.1 $225.00 Draft Defendant's Expert Interrogatories and Expert Request to Produce to Becky Ventura 4/4/2023 Plaintiff 0.5 $75.00 Email exchange with oc re: inspection and PL's objections to same; review file Becky Ventura 4/5/2023 and draft Defendant's Motion for Entry Upon Land 0.5 $75.00 Alex Perez 4/5/2023 Review and finalize Defendant's Expert Discovery Requests to Plaintiff 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/11/2023 Review PL's expert witness disclosure 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 4/13/2023 Draft Defendant's Expert Witness Disclosure 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Review and finalize Defendant's Expert Witness Disclosure 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 4/13/2023 Draft Notice of Unavailability 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Review and finalize Notice of Unavailability 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 4/13/2023 Draft Defendant's Mt for Entry Upon Land and compile exhibits 0.5 $75.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Alex Perez 4/13/2023 Finalize Defendant's Mt for Entry 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/19/2023 Review Plaintiff's NPNP 0.2 $225.00 Becky Ventura 4/20/2023 Draft Defendant's Objection to Plaintiff's NPNP 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 4/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Entry Upon Land 0.7 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/24/2023 Review Plaintiff's Witness and Exhibit List 0.6 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Finalize Defendant's Objection to NPNP 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Review Plaintiff's Notice of Hearing on Defendant's Motion for Entry 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/25/2023 Review Plaintiff's NOH on Plaintiff's NPNP 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/27/2023 Review Pl's Answers to Expert Interrogatories 0.8 $225.00 Alex Perez 4/27/2023 Review PL's Responses to Expert RP 0.6 $225.00 Becky Ventura 4/28/2023 Draft Defendant's Witness and Exhibit List 0.6 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/4/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on Def's Objection to PL's NPNP 0.1 $225.00 Draft Defendant's Notice of Serving PFS and Proposal for Settlement to Becky Ventura 5/10/2023 Plaintiff 0.8 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Finalize Defendant's PFS to PL 0.3 $225.00 Draft Defendant's Motion for Leave to Amend AAD and proposed Amended Becky Ventura 5/10/2023 AAD 0.6 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Finalize Def's Mt for Leave to Amend Answer and Affirmative Defenses 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Review Order Overruling Objections to PL's NPNP 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/10/2023 Review Order Denying Def's MTC 0.2 $225.00 Review file and draft Defendant's Response to PL's MSJ as to 1st Affirmative Alex Perez 5/15/2023 Defense 2 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/17/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MSJ 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 5/17/2023 RR email from oc re: deposition of William Clemons 0.1 $75.00 Review PL's NOH on PL's MTC Compliance w/Court Order, MTC Depo of Alex Perez 5/18/2023 William Clemmons, and Def's Mt for Leave to Amend 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.2 $225.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/18/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of Mediation 0.1 $225.00 Email exchange with oc re: hearings on Defendant's Mt for Leave, and PL's Heather Payne 5/18/2023 MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.3 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/22/2023 Review PL's Response in Opposition to Def's Mt for Leave to Amend 0.8 $225.00 Becky Ventura 5/24/2023 Email to oc enclosing 2015 claim information 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/25/2023 Review PL's NOTD of William Clemmons 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 5/25/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 5/25/2023 Draft Order on Def's Mt for Leave 0.2 $75.00 Heather Payne 5/25/2023 Email exchange with oc re: FA depo 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 5/30/2023 Review PL's Mt for Leave to File Amended W&E List (with Amended W&E List) 0.5 $225.00 Email exchange with oc re: PL's Mt for Leave to Amend Witness and Exhibit Alex Perez 5/30/2023 List 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 6/6/2023 email exchange with oc re: scheduling deposition of Jill Clement 0.3 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/7/2023 Review PL's Amended NOTD Duces Tecum of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 6/8/2023 Email exchange with oc re: deposition of Defendant's expert 0.2 $75.00 Review file and draft Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's MSJ as to 2nd Alex Perez 6/9/2023 Affirmative Defense 2.5 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/14/2023 Review PL's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/15/2023 Review PL's Notice of Service of Mt for Sanctions 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/15/2023 Review PL's 3rd set of Interrogatories 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/16/2023 Review PL's 2nd RP 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's NOTD of Def's CR 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's MSJ as to Def's 3rd Affirmative Defense 1.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review Amended Ntc of Mediation 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review PL's Mt to Strike Def's Mt for Leave to Amend AAD 0.6 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review Order on PL's MTC Compliance w/Court Order 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/19/2023 Review order on PL's MTC Depo of William Clemons 0.1 $225.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Heather Payne 6/19/2023 email to oc re: mediation 0.1 $75.00 Review claim file, review Plaintiff's deposition transcript, and begin drafting Becky Ventura 6/20/2023 outline for Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 1 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review Plaintiff's notice of hearing on Plaintiff's MTC Docs per Court Order 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of Depo of Jill Clement 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Review Ntc of Cancellation of Depo of CR 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/20/2023 Draft Defendant's MIL re: PL's Witnesses 1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 6/21/2023 Draft Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. 3.5 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/21/2023 Review PL's 4th Interrogatories to Def 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/21/2023 Review PL's 2nd RA to Def 0.3 $225.00 Becky Ventura 6/22/2023 Review draft MSJ with atty. 0.3 $75.00 Becky Ventura 6/23/2023 Begin compiling trial exhibits. 1 $75.00 Becky Ventura 6/23/2023 Review file and draft Defendant's Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses. 0.6 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/26/2023 Review Plaintiff's Ntc of Cancellation of hearing on MSJ 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 6/26/2023 Draft Affidavit of CR in support of Def's MSJ; compile exhibits to MSJ. 0.4 $75.00 Becky Ventura 6/26/2023 Prepare mediation folder. 0.9 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/26/2023 RR PL's proposed Joint Pre-Trial Statement 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/27/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MIL re: damages 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Draft Defendant's Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories. 0.6 $75.00 Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Email to oc re: proposed Agreed Order on PL's MTC Answers to 2nd Rogs (x3) 0.2 $75.00 Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Prepare hearing folder for 6/29 hearing on PL's MTC answers to 2nd rogs. 0.3 $75.00 Draft and file Defendant's Notice of Compliance re: Defendant's Answers to Becky Ventura 6/28/2023 Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $75.00 Email exchange w/oc re: unilaterally set hearings on Plaintiff's motions in Becky Ventura 6/29/2023 limine. 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 6/29/2023 Review Joint Pre-Trial Statement 0.5 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/30/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on PL's MIL re: Damages 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 6/30/2023 Review mediation disposition report 0.1 $225.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 finalize and file MSJ 0.7 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/12/2023 Finalize Defendant's MSJ 1.1 $225.00 Draft and File Notice of Filing Transcript of Sharon Muirhead's Depo in Support Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 of Def's MSJ 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/12/2023 Finalize affidavit of CR 0.2 $225.00 Becky Ventura 7/12/2023 Draft and file Ntc of Filing CR Affidavit 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/12/2023 email exchange with oc re: CMC 0.4 $225.00 Becky Ventura 7/17/2023 Draft Defendant's Mt for Continuance 0.8 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/17/2023 Finalize Defendant's Mt for Continuance 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 7/19/2023 Review PL's MTCBA to PL's 2nd Set of Interrogatories 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 7/19/2023 Review PL's MTC Discovery Responses 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 7/20/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MTC Disco Responses 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 7/21/2023 Draft and file NOH on Def's Mt for Continuance 0.2 $75.00 Becky Ventura 7/21/2023 Draft Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff's 2nd Request for Admissions 0.5 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/21/2023 Finalize Defendant's Responses to PL's 2nd RA 0.2 $225.00 Becky Ventura 7/21/2023 Draft Def's Responses to PL's 2nd RP 0.3 $75.00 Alex Perez 7/21/2023 Finalize Defendant's Responses to PL's 2nd RP 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 7/26/2023 Review Order Denying Def's Mt to Continue 0.2 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/1/2023 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's MTCBA to 2nd set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Review PL's Notice of Cancellation of hearing on MSJ 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Draft Defendant's answers to PL's 3rd Interrogatories 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Finalize Defendant's answers to PL's 3rd Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Draft Defendant's answers to PL's 4th set of Interrogatories 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Finalize Defendant's answers to PL's 4th set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Draft Defendant's Amended Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of Becky Ventura 8/2/2023 Interrogatories 0.6 $75.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Finalize Defendant's Amended Answers to Plaintiff's Second Set of Alex Perez 8/2/2023 Interrogatories 0.2 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/3/2023 Draft and file Notice of Cancellation of Depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 2nd Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 3rd Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/3/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Filing Def's Answers to 4th Set of Interrogatories 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/3/2023 email exchange with oc re: depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/10/2023 Draft and file re-notice of taking depo duces tecum of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/11/2023 Review verified return of non service re: PA 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 8/11/2023 email exchange with oc re: updated depo of PL 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/14/2023 Review Order on PL's MIL re: Damages 0.2 $225.00 Becky Ventura 8/14/2023 Draft Defendant's Motion to Compel Depo or Mt to Strike PL's Expert 0.5 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/15/2023 Finalize Defendant's Motion to Compel Depo or Mt to Strike PL's Expert 0.2 $225.00 Becky Ventura 8/15/2023 Draft Defendant's MTC PL's Continued Depo and Mt for Sanctions 0.8 $75.00 Heather Payne 8/16/2023 Draft and file NOH on Def's MTC Depo/Motion to Strike Pl's Expert 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/16/2023 Prepare for deposition of Destiny Muirhead 2 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/17/2023 Attend depo of Destiny Muirhead 1 $225.00 Draft and file amended NOH on MTC Depo of Expert and MTC PL's Continued Heather Payne 8/18/2023 Depo 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/18/2023 Finalize Def's MTC PL's Continued Depo and Mt for Sanctions 0.2 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/20/2023 Review PL's Cross Notice of Hearing on Def's MTC Second Depo of PL 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/20/2023 Review PL's Response to Def's MTC Depo 0.3 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/21/2023 Review CNA of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/21/2023 email exchange with oc re: depo of PL 0.5 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/22/2023 Review Plaintiff's Objections to Duces Tecum requesdt re: depo of Plaintiff 0.5 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/22/2023 Draft and file NOTD Duces Tecum of Anthony Jaffa 0.3 $75.00 Heather Payne 8/22/2023 Draft and file Def's 2nd Re-Notice of Taking Depo of Destiny Muirhead 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/22/2023 Review PL's Mt to Strike Def's Expert Witness List 0.2 $225.00 Exhibit A Time Personnel Date Description spent Rate Review PL's Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum of Defendant's Expert, Alex Perez 8/23/2023 Daniel Cross 0.3 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/23/2023 Draft NOTD Duces Tecum of RC of Grove Construction 0.2 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/23/2023 Review file and prepare for second deposition of Destiny Muirhead 3 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/24/2023 attend 2nd depo of Sharon Muirhead 1 $225.00 Draft and file Def's 4th Re-Notice of Taking Depo Duces Tecum of Destiny Heather Payne 8/25/2023 Muirhead 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/25/2023 Review file and prepare for deposition of Destiny Muirhead 2 $225.00 Heather Payne 8/25/2023 RR email from oc re: trial docket 0.1 $75.00 Alex Perez 8/26/2023 Review PL's Ntc of Settlement 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 8/26/2023 Attend depo of Destiny Muirhead 1 $225.00 Alex Perez 11/27/2023 Review PL's NOH on PL's Mt for Interest 0.1 $225.00 Alex Perez 12/6/2023 Review PL's Amended NOH on PL's Mt for Interest and PL's Mt for Sanctions 0.1 $225.00 Becky Ventura 12/7/2023 Begin drafting Defendant's Amended Responses to Attorney Fee Discovery. 0.2 $75.00 1/10/2022 - Laura Rodriguez 02/15/23 email exchange with oc re: scheduling PL's depo 0.7 $75.00 4/13/2023 - Heather Payne 4/24/23 email exchange with oc re: hearing on Def's MTC Entry 0.4 $75.00 5/12/23 - Heather Payne 5/15/23 email exchange with oc re: hearing on MSJ 0.3 $75.00 6/26/2023 - Alex Perez 6/27/23 email exchange with oc re: joint pre-trial statement and exhibit exchange 0.4 $225.00 7/26/2023 Alex Perez 7/27/23 email exchange with oc re: deposition of Destiny Muirhead 0.2 $225.00 Exhibit A