On September 29, 2010 a
Appellate Materials
was filed
involving a dispute between
Melinda Coker,
and
Ocwen Loan Servicing Llc,
for LIBEL/SLANDER
in the District Court of Palm Beach County.
Preview
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIRCUIT CIVIL / PROBATE DIVISION
CASE NO.: 502010CA024666XXXMB
FOURTH DISTRICT CASE NO.: 4D13-827
MELINDA COKER
vs.
OCWEN LOAN SERVICING, LLC, ETC.
/
INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL
COPIES FURNISHED TO:
HENRY L. KAYE, ESQ.
KAY LAW FIRM, PLLC
325 11™ STREET
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401
BRIAN R. KOELOWITZ, ESQ.
KOPELOWITZ OSTROW FERGUSON ET AL, P.A.
200 SW 1ST AVENUE, 12 FLOOR
FORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33301.
“|
Es Hd 8- Udv E102Report: CZRAPRE CI CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M.
Instance: JISPROD Page: 1
Case ID: 2010CA024666
Appeal Seq.: 1
Index No.: 1
Appeal Type: FINAL
Index Type: ORIGINAL
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
Filing Date Doc No Description
Text/Notes
VOLUME NUMBER ONE
09/29/2010 00000001 COMPLAINT
09/29/2010 00000002 CIVIL COVER SHEET
11/05/2010 00000004 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN
11/05/2010 00000005 MOTION TO DISMISS
12/10/2010 00000007 NOTICE OF FILING
NOTICE OF REMOVAL IN FEDERAL COURT
02/10/2011 00000008 CERTIFIED COPY
OF ORDER OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO CIRCUIT
04/05/2011 00000012 RESPONSE TO:
TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
04/05/2011 00000014 MOTION TO STRIKE
04/05/2011 00000015 MOTION
FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR COURT TO ORDER
CANCELLATION OF DEPO
04/27/2011 00000019, MOTION
10
11
14
16
19
21
10
13
15
18
20
22Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate:
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime:
Instance: JISPROD Page:
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
Filing Date Doc No Description
Text/Notes
FOR SANCTIONS
05/02/2011 00000016 MOTION
FOR SANCTIONS
05/02/2011 00000018 MEMORANDUM
IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN OPPOSITION TO
DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS
06/29/2011 00000024 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
06/30/2011 00000025 MOTION
OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR DEPO
06/29/2012 00000029 MOTION TO COMPEL
07/26/2012 00000033 ORDER GRANTING
DEFT MOT TO COMPEL TMCCARTHY
09/28/2012 00000037 MOTION
FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE
08-APR-2013
03:48 P.M.
2
23
25
28
29
31
Sl
S2
PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS. AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FOR.
SEPTEMBER 24, 2012
10/17/2012 00000038 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
11/06/2012 00000039 ORDER SETTING HEARING
SET FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY)
01/14/2013 00000040 AFFIDAVIT
OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY
IMT
61
66
68
24
27
28
30
50
51
60
65.
67
70Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M.
Instance: JISPROD Page: 3
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
Filing Date Doc No Description
Text/Notes
01/22/2013 00000041 ORDER
ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT: GRANTED E
FINE
01/22/2013 00000042 REPLY/RESPONSE
TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT MOT FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
02/11/2013 00000043 FINAL JUDGMENT
PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E FINE
03/04/2013 00000044 NOTICE OF APPEAL
TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 2/8/13 & ORDER
RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES ATTACHED
04/08/2013 CERTIFICATE OF CLERK - MAILING INDEX
*** END OF REPORT ***
Number of records printed: 24
71
72
95
96
71
94
95
100Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M.
Instance: JISPROD Page: 1
Case ID: 2010CA024666
Appeal Seq.: 1
Index No.: 1
Appeal Type: FINAL
Index Type: ORIGINAL
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
Filing Date Doc No Description
Text/Notes
VOLUME NUMBER ONE
09/29/2010 00000001 COMPLAINT
03/29/2010 00000002 CIVIL COVER SHEET
11/05/2010 00000004 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN
11/05/2010 00000005 MOTION TO DISMISS
12/10/2010 00000007 NOTICE OF FILING
NOTICE OF REMOVAL IN FEDERAL COURT
02/10/2011 00000008 CERTIFIED COPY
OF ORDER OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO CIRCUIT
04/05/2011 00000012 RESPONSE TO:
TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
04/05/2011 00000014 MOTION TO STRIKE
04/05/2011 00000015 MOTION
FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR COURT TO ORDER
CANCELLATION OF DEPO
04/27/2011 00000019 MOTION
10
a1
14
16
19
21
10
13
1s
18
20
22Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY ‘CIR CT JISPROD RunDate:
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime:
Instance: JISPROD. Page:
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
Filing Date Doc No Description
Text/Notes
FOR SANCTIONS
05/02/2011 00000016 MOTION
FOR SANCTIONS
05/02/2011 00000018 MEMORANDUM
IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN OPPOSITION TO
DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS
06/29/2011 00000024 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
06/30/2011 00000025 MOTION
OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR DEPO
06/29/2012 00000029 MOTION TO COMPEL
07/26/2012 00000033 ORDER GRANTING
DEFT MOT TO COMPEL TMCCARTHY
09/28/2012 00000037 MOTION
FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE
PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FO:
SEPTEMBER 24, 2012
10/17/2012 00000038 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
11/06/2012 00000039 ORDER SETTING HEARING
SET FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY)
01/14/2013 00000040 AFFIDAVIT
OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY
OMT
08-APR-2013
03:48 P.M.
2
23
25
28
29
31
51
52
R
61
66
68
24
27
28
30
50
51
60
65
67
70Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013
User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M.
Instance: JISPROD Page: 3
Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING.
Filing Date Doc No Description Page
Text/Notes Range
01/22/2013 00000041 ORDER 71 71
ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT: GRANTED E
FINE
01/22/2013 00000042 REPLY / RESPONSE. 72 94
TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT MOT FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
02/11/2013 00000043 FINAL JUDGMENT 95 95,
PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E FINE
03/04/2013 00000044 NOTICE OF APPEAL 96 100
TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 2/8/13 & ORDER
RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES ATTACHED
04/08/2013 CERTIFICATE OF CLERK ~ MAILING INDEX
*** END OF REPORT ***
Number of records printed: 24CERTIFICATE OF CLERK
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH )
I, SHARON R. BOCK, Clerk of Circuit Court for the County
of Palm Beach, State of Florida, do hereby certify that the
foregoing pages 1 to 100 inclusive, consists of original
papers and proceedings in Civil Action Case Number:
502010CA024666XXXXMB- MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING
4D13-827- MELINDA COKER v. OCWEN LOAN SERVICING, LLC, ETC.
as appears from the records and files of my office which have
been directed to be included in said Record; pursuant to Florida
Rules of Appellate Procedure, 9.200(a) (1).
IN WITNESS WHEREOF,
I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the
of said Court this 8TH day of APRIL, 2013 A.D.
SHARON R. BOCK, Clerk of Circuit Court
Palm Beach County, Florida
By:
(Circuit Court Seal) Deputy ClerkReport: | CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013
Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: 3:48:05PM
Docket Print from Easyview
Page 1 of 5
Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010CA024866XXXXMB.
Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED
Case Type Court Location Division Jury
YI-LIBEUSLANDER CA MB AE J
Type Party Name Represented by
JUDGE FINE, JUDGE EDWARD H
PLAINTIFF. COKER, MELINDA KAYE, HENRY L
DEFENDANT OCWEN LOAN SERVICING LLC KOPELOWITZ, BRIAN
Filing Date___DocketNo Pages Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text Book No __ Page No
29-Sep-2010 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ____00909.__ "1 CC ORDER SUM TBD ~ |
RECEIPT FOR PAYMENT “A Payment of -$411.00 was made on receipt
__ CAMB469293.
~ COMPLAINT _
ecb;Son 20 (0 Ese eee ~SM10-147006 ee
15-Oct-2010 SERVICE RETURN SRTN SUMMONS SERVED 10/5/10
(ATTACHED)
05.Nov2010 4 1__NOTICEOF APPEARANCE —————sNOAP__OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN
~ON sano
NOTICE OF = REMOVAL INF FEDERAL COURT __
10-Dec-2010 cece es DISPOSED - OTHER
AOFeb-2011 _REOPEN
10-Feb-2011 8 3. CERTIFIED COPY copy OF cme (OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO
CIRCUIT
(czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013
Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time 3:48:05PM
Docket Print from Easyview
Page 2 of 5
Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010C,A024656XXXXMB
Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED
Filing Date Docket No Pages Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text Book No Page No
18-Feb-2011 9 7 RESPONSE TO REQ FOR RERQ TO PLTF 1ST
(24-Feb-2011 10 NOTD "(VIDEOTAPED) OF MELINDA COKER on. anit
O1-Apr-2011 41 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD _(VIDEOTAPED) OF MELINDA COKER ON 4/20/11
a DEPOSITION ee
O5-Apr-2011 12 RESPONSETO: RESP___TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER _
05-Apr-2011
05-Apr-2011
MOTION TO STRIKE
05-Apr-2011 15 2 MOTION MOT FOR eon OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR
= TO ORDER CANCEL! o
2. MOTION ______MOT FOR SANCTIONS
9 __ NOTICE OF SERVICE NOS _OF INTERROGS
(02-May-2011 18 3. MEMORANDUM MEMO —_IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN
OPPOSITION TO DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS
7 ___.TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS
23-May-2011 20 2 NOTICE OF TAKING NOTD JOY ROTHENBERGER 7/6/11
DEPOSITION
13-Jun-2011 a 2 SUSHOENA RETURNED /
SERVE
15-Jun-2011 22 NOTICE OF FILING
28-Jun-2011 23 3 NOTICE. OF TAKING (AMENDED) OF JOY ROTHENBERGER ON 7/6/11 -
a . DEPOSITION .
_ _ NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILI
30-Jun-2011 25 2 MOTION
OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA
FOR DEPO
(czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013
Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: 3:48:05PM
Docket Print from Easyview
Page 3 of 5
Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : $02010CA024666 XXXXMB
Case Filed : 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED
Filing Date___DocketNo _Pages__ Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text BookNo _ Page No
23-Sep-2011 26 3. RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD
DEPOSITION
05-Oct-2011 7 7___ REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO PLT
05-Oct-2011 28 1 NOTICE OF SERVING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO
———————————EE Ee _PLAINTIFE Se
29-Jun-2012 29 20 MOTIONTOCOMPEL _
05-Jul-2012 30 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD MELINDA COKER AUG 8 2012
_ _ DEPOSITION _ ee oe
05-Jul-2012 2 NOTICE OF HEARING JULY 18 2012 8:45. = rt
23-Jul-2012 HEARING ON: T2612
26-Jul-2012 3 1___ORDERGRANTING = ORDG_—_DEFT MOT TO . a
03-Aug-2012 34 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD OF MELINDA COKER ON 9724/12
DEPOSITION _ _ _ . _
21-Aug-2012 36 1 NOTICE NOT OF SERVING RESPONSE TO DEFT REQ TO
—__- ee ROC
_2t-Aug-2012 __NOT ___OF SERVING ANSWERS TO DEFT INTERROGS
26-Sep-2012 MOT FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST i
TO PRODUCE PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS
AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FOR SEPTEMBER
24, 201
17-Oct-2012 38 5 MOTION FOR SUMMARY
_ . ___ JUDGMENT pe : Pe eee 2 —
06-Nov-2012 39 2 ORDERSETTINGHEARING __ORSH SI FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY) _
14-Jan-2013 40 3 AFFIDAVIT AFF OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
. . ence FOR SUMMARY JMT
22-Jan-2013 DEFENDANTS.
MOTION FOR
(cztezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT
Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY
Docket Print from Easyview
Date: 08-Apr-2013
Time: 3:48:05PM
Page 4 of 5
Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010CA024666XXXXMB
Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED
Filing Date _DocketNo__Pages_ Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text BookNo_ __ Page No
22-Jan-2013 42 23. 'REPLY/RESPONSE RPRS TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
a a Oe MOT EORISUUMAR aa oe
14-Feb-2013 43 1 FINAL JUDGMENT FJUD —_PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E 025791 00842
—— ee FINE Se : - :
ao ——————————————————————— a es
04-Mar-2013 . CAFFINOA) 801FF ae . a ee
(04-Mar-2013 RECEIPT FOR PAYMENT RCPT A Payment of -$100.00 was made on receipt
_ tn CAMB761862, ete
04-Mar-2013 NOTICE OF APPEAL NOA TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 25854 1895
2/8/13 & ORDER RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES
= ee Ae : ee
1 ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW ACKC CASE 4D13-827 7
CASE
(czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: . CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013
Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: —-3:48:05PM
Docket Print from Easyview
Page 5 of 5
Case ID: 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : $02010CA024666XXXXMB.
Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS - REDISPOSED
Docket Entries : 55
Last Aaivity
*** end of report czezdk ***
{czrezdk) Revised : 28-Ju+-2003
Document Filed Date
December 17, 2057
Case Filing Date
September 29, 2010
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CIRCUIT CIVIL / PROBATE DIVISION CASE NO.: 502010CA024666XXXMB FOURTH DISTRICT CASE NO.: 4D13-827 MELINDA COKER vs. OCWEN LOAN SERVICING, LLC, ETC. / INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL COPIES FURNISHED TO: HENRY L. KAYE, ESQ. KAY LAW FIRM, PLLC 325 11™ STREET WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401 BRIAN R. KOELOWITZ, ESQ. KOPELOWITZ OSTROW FERGUSON ET AL, P.A. 200 SW 1ST AVENUE, 12 FLOOR FORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33301. “| Es Hd 8- Udv E102Report: CZRAPRE CI CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013 User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M. Instance: JISPROD Page: 1 Case ID: 2010CA024666 Appeal Seq.: 1 Index No.: 1 Appeal Type: FINAL Index Type: ORIGINAL Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING Filing Date Doc No Description Text/Notes VOLUME NUMBER ONE 09/29/2010 00000001 COMPLAINT 09/29/2010 00000002 CIVIL COVER SHEET 11/05/2010 00000004 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN 11/05/2010 00000005 MOTION TO DISMISS 12/10/2010 00000007 NOTICE OF FILING NOTICE OF REMOVAL IN FEDERAL COURT 02/10/2011 00000008 CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO CIRCUIT 04/05/2011 00000012 RESPONSE TO: TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 04/05/2011 00000014 MOTION TO STRIKE 04/05/2011 00000015 MOTION FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR COURT TO ORDER CANCELLATION OF DEPO 04/27/2011 00000019, MOTION 10 11 14 16 19 21 10 13 15 18 20 22Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: Instance: JISPROD Page: Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING Filing Date Doc No Description Text/Notes FOR SANCTIONS 05/02/2011 00000016 MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 05/02/2011 00000018 MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS 06/29/2011 00000024 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 06/30/2011 00000025 MOTION OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR DEPO 06/29/2012 00000029 MOTION TO COMPEL 07/26/2012 00000033 ORDER GRANTING DEFT MOT TO COMPEL TMCCARTHY 09/28/2012 00000037 MOTION FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 08-APR-2013 03:48 P.M. 2 23 25 28 29 31 Sl S2 PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS. AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FOR. SEPTEMBER 24, 2012 10/17/2012 00000038 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 11/06/2012 00000039 ORDER SETTING HEARING SET FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY) 01/14/2013 00000040 AFFIDAVIT OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY IMT 61 66 68 24 27 28 30 50 51 60 65. 67 70Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013 User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M. Instance: JISPROD Page: 3 Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING Filing Date Doc No Description Text/Notes 01/22/2013 00000041 ORDER ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT: GRANTED E FINE 01/22/2013 00000042 REPLY/RESPONSE TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT MOT FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 02/11/2013 00000043 FINAL JUDGMENT PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E FINE 03/04/2013 00000044 NOTICE OF APPEAL TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 2/8/13 & ORDER RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES ATTACHED 04/08/2013 CERTIFICATE OF CLERK - MAILING INDEX *** END OF REPORT *** Number of records printed: 24 71 72 95 96 71 94 95 100Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013 User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M. Instance: JISPROD Page: 1 Case ID: 2010CA024666 Appeal Seq.: 1 Index No.: 1 Appeal Type: FINAL Index Type: ORIGINAL Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING Filing Date Doc No Description Text/Notes VOLUME NUMBER ONE 09/29/2010 00000001 COMPLAINT 03/29/2010 00000002 CIVIL COVER SHEET 11/05/2010 00000004 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN 11/05/2010 00000005 MOTION TO DISMISS 12/10/2010 00000007 NOTICE OF FILING NOTICE OF REMOVAL IN FEDERAL COURT 02/10/2011 00000008 CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO CIRCUIT 04/05/2011 00000012 RESPONSE TO: TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 04/05/2011 00000014 MOTION TO STRIKE 04/05/2011 00000015 MOTION FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR COURT TO ORDER CANCELLATION OF DEPO 04/27/2011 00000019 MOTION 10 a1 14 16 19 21 10 13 1s 18 20 22Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY ‘CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: Instance: JISPROD. Page: Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING Filing Date Doc No Description Text/Notes FOR SANCTIONS 05/02/2011 00000016 MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 05/02/2011 00000018 MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS 06/29/2011 00000024 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 06/30/2011 00000025 MOTION OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR DEPO 06/29/2012 00000029 MOTION TO COMPEL 07/26/2012 00000033 ORDER GRANTING DEFT MOT TO COMPEL TMCCARTHY 09/28/2012 00000037 MOTION FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FO: SEPTEMBER 24, 2012 10/17/2012 00000038 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 11/06/2012 00000039 ORDER SETTING HEARING SET FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY) 01/14/2013 00000040 AFFIDAVIT OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY OMT 08-APR-2013 03:48 P.M. 2 23 25 28 29 31 51 52 R 61 66 68 24 27 28 30 50 51 60 65 67 70Report: CZRAPRE PALM BEACH CTY CIR CT JISPROD RunDate: 08-APR-2013 User: CMARKISEN Record on Appeal Report TEST 03-09-03 RunTime: 03:48 P.M. Instance: JISPROD Page: 3 Case Description: MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING. Filing Date Doc No Description Page Text/Notes Range 01/22/2013 00000041 ORDER 71 71 ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT: GRANTED E FINE 01/22/2013 00000042 REPLY / RESPONSE. 72 94 TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT MOT FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 02/11/2013 00000043 FINAL JUDGMENT 95 95, PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E FINE 03/04/2013 00000044 NOTICE OF APPEAL 96 100 TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 2/8/13 & ORDER RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES ATTACHED 04/08/2013 CERTIFICATE OF CLERK ~ MAILING INDEX *** END OF REPORT *** Number of records printed: 24CERTIFICATE OF CLERK STATE OF FLORIDA ) COUNTY OF PALM BEACH ) I, SHARON R. BOCK, Clerk of Circuit Court for the County of Palm Beach, State of Florida, do hereby certify that the foregoing pages 1 to 100 inclusive, consists of original papers and proceedings in Civil Action Case Number: 502010CA024666XXXXMB- MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING 4D13-827- MELINDA COKER v. OCWEN LOAN SERVICING, LLC, ETC. as appears from the records and files of my office which have been directed to be included in said Record; pursuant to Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, 9.200(a) (1). IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the of said Court this 8TH day of APRIL, 2013 A.D. SHARON R. BOCK, Clerk of Circuit Court Palm Beach County, Florida By: (Circuit Court Seal) Deputy ClerkReport: | CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013 Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: 3:48:05PM Docket Print from Easyview Page 1 of 5 Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010CA024866XXXXMB. Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED Case Type Court Location Division Jury YI-LIBEUSLANDER CA MB AE J Type Party Name Represented by JUDGE FINE, JUDGE EDWARD H PLAINTIFF. COKER, MELINDA KAYE, HENRY L DEFENDANT OCWEN LOAN SERVICING LLC KOPELOWITZ, BRIAN Filing Date___DocketNo Pages Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text Book No __ Page No 29-Sep-2010 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ____00909.__ "1 CC ORDER SUM TBD ~ | RECEIPT FOR PAYMENT “A Payment of -$411.00 was made on receipt __ CAMB469293. ~ COMPLAINT _ ecb;Son 20 (0 Ese eee ~SM10-147006 ee 15-Oct-2010 SERVICE RETURN SRTN SUMMONS SERVED 10/5/10 (ATTACHED) 05.Nov2010 4 1__NOTICEOF APPEARANCE —————sNOAP__OF ATTY BRIAN KOPELOWITZ FOR DEFT OCWEN ~ON sano NOTICE OF = REMOVAL INF FEDERAL COURT __ 10-Dec-2010 cece es DISPOSED - OTHER AOFeb-2011 _REOPEN 10-Feb-2011 8 3. CERTIFIED COPY copy OF cme (OF REMAND FROM US DISTRICT TO CIRCUIT (czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013 Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time 3:48:05PM Docket Print from Easyview Page 2 of 5 Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010C,A024656XXXXMB Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED Filing Date Docket No Pages Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text Book No Page No 18-Feb-2011 9 7 RESPONSE TO REQ FOR RERQ TO PLTF 1ST (24-Feb-2011 10 NOTD "(VIDEOTAPED) OF MELINDA COKER on. anit O1-Apr-2011 41 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD _(VIDEOTAPED) OF MELINDA COKER ON 4/20/11 a DEPOSITION ee O5-Apr-2011 12 RESPONSETO: RESP___TO MOT FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER _ 05-Apr-2011 05-Apr-2011 MOTION TO STRIKE 05-Apr-2011 15 2 MOTION MOT FOR eon OF PROTECTION & REQ FOR = TO ORDER CANCEL! o 2. MOTION ______MOT FOR SANCTIONS 9 __ NOTICE OF SERVICE NOS _OF INTERROGS (02-May-2011 18 3. MEMORANDUM MEMO —_IN SUPPORT OF ORDER OF PROTECTION & IN OPPOSITION TO DEFT HAVING FREE ACCESS 7 ___.TO PLTF PRIVILEGE TAX RETURNS 23-May-2011 20 2 NOTICE OF TAKING NOTD JOY ROTHENBERGER 7/6/11 DEPOSITION 13-Jun-2011 a 2 SUSHOENA RETURNED / SERVE 15-Jun-2011 22 NOTICE OF FILING 28-Jun-2011 23 3 NOTICE. OF TAKING (AMENDED) OF JOY ROTHENBERGER ON 7/6/11 - a . DEPOSITION . _ _ NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILI 30-Jun-2011 25 2 MOTION OF JOY ROTHENBERGER-TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR DEPO (czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013 Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: 3:48:05PM Docket Print from Easyview Page 3 of 5 Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : $02010CA024666 XXXXMB Case Filed : 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED Filing Date___DocketNo _Pages__ Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text BookNo _ Page No 23-Sep-2011 26 3. RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD DEPOSITION 05-Oct-2011 7 7___ REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO PLT 05-Oct-2011 28 1 NOTICE OF SERVING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO ———————————EE Ee _PLAINTIFE Se 29-Jun-2012 29 20 MOTIONTOCOMPEL _ 05-Jul-2012 30 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD MELINDA COKER AUG 8 2012 _ _ DEPOSITION _ ee oe 05-Jul-2012 2 NOTICE OF HEARING JULY 18 2012 8:45. = rt 23-Jul-2012 HEARING ON: T2612 26-Jul-2012 3 1___ORDERGRANTING = ORDG_—_DEFT MOT TO . a 03-Aug-2012 34 2 RE-NOTICE OF TAKING RNTD OF MELINDA COKER ON 9724/12 DEPOSITION _ _ _ . _ 21-Aug-2012 36 1 NOTICE NOT OF SERVING RESPONSE TO DEFT REQ TO —__- ee ROC _2t-Aug-2012 __NOT ___OF SERVING ANSWERS TO DEFT INTERROGS 26-Sep-2012 MOT FOR ORDER OF PROTECTION AS TO REQUEST i TO PRODUCE PERSONAL INCOME TAX RETURNS AT DEPOSITION SCHEDULED FOR SEPTEMBER 24, 201 17-Oct-2012 38 5 MOTION FOR SUMMARY _ . ___ JUDGMENT pe : Pe eee 2 — 06-Nov-2012 39 2 ORDERSETTINGHEARING __ORSH SI FOR 22-JAN-13 ( T. MCCARTHY) _ 14-Jan-2013 40 3 AFFIDAVIT AFF OF MELINDA COKER IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION . . ence FOR SUMMARY JMT 22-Jan-2013 DEFENDANTS. MOTION FOR (cztezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Docket Print from Easyview Date: 08-Apr-2013 Time: 3:48:05PM Page 4 of 5 Case ID : 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : 502010CA024666XXXXMB Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS- REDISPOSED Filing Date _DocketNo__Pages_ Docket Description Docket Code Docket Text BookNo_ __ Page No 22-Jan-2013 42 23. 'REPLY/RESPONSE RPRS TO PLTF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION a a Oe MOT EORISUUMAR aa oe 14-Feb-2013 43 1 FINAL JUDGMENT FJUD —_PLTF SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THIS ACTION. E 025791 00842 —— ee FINE Se : - : ao ——————————————————————— a es 04-Mar-2013 . CAFFINOA) 801FF ae . a ee (04-Mar-2013 RECEIPT FOR PAYMENT RCPT A Payment of -$100.00 was made on receipt _ tn CAMB761862, ete 04-Mar-2013 NOTICE OF APPEAL NOA TO 4DCA - FINAL JUDGMENT RENDERED ON 25854 1895 2/8/13 & ORDER RENDERED ON 1/22/13 - COPIES = ee Ae : ee 1 ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW ACKC CASE 4D13-827 7 CASE (czrezdk) Revised : 28-Jul-2003Report: . CZREZDK CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Date: 08-Apr-2013 Instance: JISPROD PALM BEACH COUNTY Time: —-3:48:05PM Docket Print from Easyview Page 5 of 5 Case ID: 2010CA024666 - MELINDA COKER V OCWEN LOAN SERVICING UCN : $02010CA024666XXXXMB. Case Filed: 29-Sep-2010 Status : AS - REDISPOSED Docket Entries : 55 Last Aaivity *** end of report czezdk *** {czrezdk) Revised : 28-Ju+-2003